I have a possible solution which no-one else has yet suggested. It has the virtue of simplicity.
I'd consider the following answers equivalent to my solution (you might not agree):
The OP gets a bounty from me if:
Double bounty if:
Update after reading OP's solution: yay! Nailed it. :)
They only steal it on the days John is in though; that's why they weren't caught red handed.
If she was going to waste two weeks why didn't she just watch the fridge?
Based on the first set of clues you would assume it was John because it's only stolen on the days he's there. However she followed him on Wednesday so we know it's not John. She also followed ...
So I'm new here (please excuse any formatting issues/transgressions against community norms), but I've been thinking about this for the last few hours and here is what I have so far, culling various parts from other answers which have already been posted.
Where are you? You are in:
The wording of the poem was definitely hard to understand, but as was ...
TL;DR, FINAL TABLE:
See the following spoiler only if you really really would like to spoil all of your fun in just a second:
Ok, now let's see how it is in detail:
PART I - The beggining of the investigation
Let's make some facts that are clearly in the question preamble and should be obvious to everybody that read it all:
Uncle Wiggily and ...
The location is:
Taking letter substitution, the Textfile contents can be deduced as:
The letters i, q, and b are never reused, so we'll have to guess the first two words. A likely choice is:
As Micheal Johnson noticed, the picture of the symbols is actually hiding a RAR archive with a file in it containing coordinates to Labasa Airport, in Fiji.
I would have arrested the blonde woman. She did say she was going on a jog, and size 9 men's shoes are not uncommon for women with big feet to wear. Furthermore, someone who is dressed to the nines like her is the most likely to own both a poodle and a leash for said poodle. Leash = rope.
Furthermore, if she was going on a jog and a murder and crowd ...
I assume that bold keys pressed two times, so we have:
Enter Shift Space Space Alt F7 = / . . A B C C E F G G I I L M O P R R U Y
First, I substract the image name from the key list, IMG.GIF, and ALT F7 (command to clear cmd history), now we have:
Enter Shift Space Space = / . A B C C E L O P R R U Y
because command prompt windows is open, I assume the ...