# Tag Info

117

Question: Does everybody want a drink? The third logician answers: Reason: The first says "I don't know" because he wants a drink, but doesn't know if everybody wants one. If the first didn't want a drink, he would have answered "No". Same for the second, he wants a drink but doesn't know if the third wants one. So, the third answers "Yes" if he ...

83

If the first were sober s/he would answer yes. So the first is drunk. If the second were sober s/he would answer yes. So the second is drunk. If the third were sober s/he would answer yes. The third now has enough information to answer "no", but is too drunk to realise it.

76

Well perhaps

65

To solve this puzzle, note the key word in the text: If we employ this on each of the three parts of the puzzle text, we can get the following: So the reason your puzzle was closed is because it seems like you were telling us: So please provide suitable attribution!! ;-)

64

Because

62

Because:

55

Turns out that he drinks exactly because

43

At a minimum, one logician - the final one - must be drunk. The first two can reasonably say they don't know if they cannot drive but they think one of the later logicians might The last one knows none of the prior logicians can drive, their answer should be "yes" or "no" according to their own ability. The fact that they do not answer thus means they ...

39

At minimum? Zero.

39

Easy

39

Based on ThatOneNerdyBoy's answer, here's a 9-step solution in which all words are contained within MW

26

Well, first I have to solve the math problem, I guess.

26

I think this is... Because... Ouch! :)

23

Easy math:

22

I'm pretty sure WeShall has it, but I'd like to point out that it might be as high as if we assume that

21

Because...

19

The song is clearly supposed to be Which is a well known song by With some imagination it is pronounced the same as

18

I think

18

Here it is in 10 steps, at least

17

The answer is an anagram of The question hints at this as the unique answer by

17

Thanks to jafe for spotting this. I think the answer is Solved nonogram Reasoning

17

Overall interpretation Step 1 Step 2 Now that we have step 1 done... The solution there is: Step 3 Okay, so what next? So, we should apply this step's instruction picture: Step 4 Finally:

17

Almost all of the correct words to insert have been suggested in other users' answers, just not all together. However, I believe the true combination is: This yields: How do we interpret this? This is of course a reference to:

16

I believe the message being communicated is Getting the message took a bit of guesswork, but it checks out: Since

16

WARNING: PUN INCOMING! You can never truly 'know how many people can fit on the floor of an opera house' because: And because it always makes it funnier when you explain a joke: This also fits with the title, since:

16

The answers are, in order, and so we learn that people doing pub quizzes are (one hopes) We were told

15

First, some basic deductions: And repeat: And repeat again: And now we come to an interesting step: Now we can do something else similar, after a bit more work: These steps complete the puzzle with just the usual deductions afterwards. About halfway through, it looks like this: And the solutions to the puzzles: Now, overlaying the two puzzles, we see ...

14

because

14

Here is a possible 9 step:

Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible