My old science teacher Dr Aphorism was brilliant – not just at teaching (and, of course, science), but also at providing invaluable life advice. I always remember one day when I went to her office to talk about a coursework experiment that was not going well. She sat me down, looked at my equations, and pointed at a term involving a square root.

"I know that's the part that's wrong," I said, "but I’ve tried everything, and it just doesn’t work out."

With that, Dr Aphorism smiled and directed my attention to a poster on her wall showing a modified Periodic Table.

"I’m going to leave you here for ten minutes," she said kindly, "and I want you to focus really hard on working out the meaning behind this poster. When I come back I’m sure you’ll have a better understanding..."

TASK: What is the hidden meaning behind this poster? The (perhaps ironic) correct answer is an 8-word phrase which can be enumerated as (5, ?, 7, ?, 4, ?, 3, ?), where some word lengths have been left unknown…

enter image description here A colour guide for colour-blind solvers is available here.

  • 3
    $\begingroup$ Nice attention to detail with the thumbtacks in the corners. $\endgroup$ – msh210 Jun 8 '20 at 12:51
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ I have to get to work (an hour later than normal...thanks Stiv :-), but I noticed rot13(sbe rirel funqrq ryrzrag, gur nygrerq ngbzvp ahzore ersref gb na ryrzrag jubfr ngbzvp flzoby funerf n yrggre jvgu gur ngbzvp flzoby va gur funqrq fdhner. V gevrq uvggvat gur erfhygvat yrggref (obgu funerq naq abg-funerq, jvgu frireny pbzovangvbaf gurerbs) jvgu inevbhf Pnrfne naq Ivtarer pvcuref, ohg ab yhpx lrg.) $\endgroup$ – Jeremy Dover Jun 8 '20 at 14:14
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ So I know the phrase is rot13(bsgra n ceboyrz unf zber guna bar fbyhgvba), but I'm not sure yet of the logic to get there. Hoping the wife doesn't make me start painting the bedroom before I finish. $\endgroup$ – Jeremy Dover Jun 9 '20 at 0:04
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ @Stiv: Even thought I didn't get the checkmark, I absolutely loved this puzzle, and really appreciate the craft you put into it. Wish I could upvote multiple times :-) $\endgroup$ – Jeremy Dover Jun 9 '20 at 20:06
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ @JeremyDover Thanks, I'm glad to hear it :) It was born out of a sudden idea of "would this be possible...?" so I spent some time working out all the possible combinations that could be used, then had to devise a sentence that could be built out of them - and I was very chuffed it all worked out! Making the image in Excel was fun - plus now I have a template for future chemistry puzzles! :) $\endgroup$ – Stiv Jun 9 '20 at 20:17

First, notice that:

The numbers of colored elements are a bit off.

But if we take a look further:

The numbers are denoting other elements, which surprisingly share a common letter with the colored ones!

For example, for the RED one:

- Ni is numbered 22, denoting Ti.
- Ir is numbered 87, denoting Fr.
- Rg is numbered 118, denoting Og.
- Cf is numbered 58, denoting Ce.

But, cleverly, we don't stop here! Taking a look far further:

The numbers apparently share a common digit too!

For example, for the RED one:

- Ni is numbered 22, it should be 28.
- Ir is numbered 87, it should be 77.
- Rg is numbered 118, it should be 111.
- Cf is numbered 58, it should be 98.

So if we tabulate the results, and taking the "differences":

enter image description here

The last thing is to extract the final answer:

For each group, sort the digit differences, then pick the letter differences.

The final answer is:


Final remark (helped by the author):

So the wise word from Dr Aphorism to be "Remember that often a problem has more than one solution". If the narrator insists to correct the single mistake in his/her square root part, it indeed may be hard to solve or even impossible: instead, try to look at another angle!

Perhaps there are more than a single mistake here? Perhaps there is another way to solve the problem? @Johnson notices that square root may result not only positive but also negative solution (as many people forget!)

As illustrated in the poster (i.e. "there are not 1 but 2 mistakes" or "there are are not 1 but 2 solutions") surely Dr Aphorism knows how to teach her students a way of life! :)

  • 2
    $\begingroup$ @JeremyDover whoops, sorry if I'm sniping, I just realized that you've already covered most of these in the comments >< $\endgroup$ – athin Jun 9 '20 at 4:42
  • 4
    $\begingroup$ @athin: No sniping at all...you got it all the way there, and I didn't. I like to think I can appreciate your solution all the more because I know most of what went into it first-hand :-) Great work! $\endgroup$ – Jeremy Dover Jun 9 '20 at 11:20
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ The final answer, combined with the square root, immediately made me think of the fact that rot13(Nal cbfvgvir ahzore k jvyy unir gjb fdhner ebbgf - (cbfvgvir naq artngvir). Gur cbfvgvir ebbg vf gur bar jr hfhnyyl guvax bs, ohg creuncf gur cebs vf erzvaqvat gur fghqrag gung nabgure bar lrg rkvfgf.) $\endgroup$ – Johnson Jun 10 '20 at 2:23
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ @Johnson dang that's legit! Adding that :) $\endgroup$ – athin Jun 10 '20 at 2:28
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ To make it more precise, a square root always results in a positive number. However, when it is part of a solution to a quadratic equation, there could be two solutions: one with is the square root,and another is the negative of the square root. $\endgroup$ – justhalf Jun 10 '20 at 4:04

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.