11
$\begingroup$

It is well known that two knights and a king alone cannot force a checkmate. But that it on a 64-sqaure board.

According to Edward Winter’s C.N. 5449, William Shinkman found a way to give mate in a KNN-K endgame by adding an extra square below e1 (see the diagram on the left.)

enter image description here

The problem calls for Checkmate In 55 Moves.

Can anyone solve it? I translated some of the German and found no mention of when the solution would be published, so I don’t know where to look.

Computers are allowed. If you find a solution, it does not have to be in 55 moves, as this ancient problem could be incorrect. If there is no solution, give proof as to why.

Good luck!

P.S. Here’s a Google Scan of the volume. It’s on page 51.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Nitpick: Due to the 50 move rule, black can claim a draw before it will be mate (unless there is a knight sacrifice at least 5 moves before the mate occurs, but I find it unlikely that you can then still force mate with a single knight) $\endgroup$ – Lolgast Nov 12 at 13:34
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Checkmate can't be given with just a knight and the king. The 50 move rule doesn't apply or course. $\endgroup$ – Rewan Demontay Nov 12 at 13:42
  • $\begingroup$ Where you found it. Just read my post. And you're welcome! $\endgroup$ – Rewan Demontay Nov 13 at 4:49
5
$\begingroup$

I found/figured out the solution.

Mate can be forced by white.

Starting with the reference to this problem here:

http://www.chesshistory.com/winter/winter44.html#CN_5449

A few entries down the page, a more illuminating further reference is given:

http://www.chesshistory.com/winter/winter44.html#CN_5455

This latter entry shows the crucial mating position: White knights on g3 and e0, white king on h3, black king on g1.

To give an example of how mate can be forced, consider the following starting position, with White to move. Remember that there is an extra square on e0.

enter image description here

White can mate in 4:

  1. Nf2+ Kg1
  2. Nfe4 Kh1
  3. Ng3+ Kg1
  4. Ne0#

The diagram position doesn't look too hard to reach from an arbitrary starting position, thus allowing mate to be forced from the original position in the question.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Feel free to try to find the move sequence of 55 moves. Nice answer and great research! $\endgroup$ – Rewan Demontay Nov 13 at 4:55
3
$\begingroup$

I start by excluding mating positions.

enter image description here

If white King steps to e0 from e1 (from a normal stalemate position) the black king is outside of the red line and once the white king is on e0 there will be no attacking piece to deliver mate. If the position is not the stalemate illustrated above, but with one of the knights attacking, then white king doesn`t need to step on e0, it can go to d1 or f1.

Conclusion: white king should go to e0 from d1 or f1.

enter image description here

On the second illustration it is already mate on a normal board and we know that this is not achievable with perfect play. (It would be possible if an extra piece, for example a queen on the f1-a6 diagonal would force the king move to f1 (Qf1, Kxf1) then for example Nf5 to Ne3+, Ke0, Nf2#. (But we don`t have any extra piece)

If white king on f1 would be normally stalemated then he goes to e0, but in order to mate him on e0 the next knight jump (whichever knight and wherever the knights are) should attack e0 and f1 simultaneously, but the square d2 (the only possible square to deliver mate from) is occupied by the black king himself.

The king cannot be checkmated on f1 or d1 because the attacker would cover e0, and to cover all the 5 remaining squares surrounding the king the other knight and the black king should be placed on the same square (f3 or d3). In chess only one piece can occupy a given square at any time.

EDIT: I found a line where the king can actually be mated on e0 square.

This is a variant of the previous "second illustration" where there was mate on the board and it was stated that this couldn`t be forced. Of course not on a normal board, but what if the king steps on f1 from e0 ! So the position is achievable on an extended board. Here the line would be 1 ...Kd2 2 Ke0,Nf5 3 Kf1,Ne3+ 4 Ke0,Ng1#.

It is now proved that starting from this position the king can be mated on e0. The next question to answer is whether this position can or cannot be reached from the starting position given in the original article.

enter image description here

$\endgroup$
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ It doesn't say that checkmate has to be around that square, right? How do you know that checkmate isn't possible anywhere else? $\endgroup$ – jazhang Nov 12 at 17:54
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ hmm... I will have to take a look at other options too.. $\endgroup$ – balazs.com Nov 12 at 18:01
  • $\begingroup$ More than one solution now it seems to me. That’s just fantastic! $\endgroup$ – Rewan Demontay Nov 13 at 12:57
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ To me it seems that there are two different mating positions already prooved ( the other one discovered by isaacg), I managed to exclude some mates,but this was good only for narrowing down the possibilites. The relevant questions arising are: Can we get to these (one of these, more of these, or neither of these) positions from the given starting point. $\endgroup$ – balazs.com Nov 13 at 13:02
  • $\begingroup$ That is a good point. Brute forcing.it or something should be relatively simple. The only hard part Is coding in the extra square. Other than that, it's a normal chess board with 4 pieces on it. $\endgroup$ – Rewan Demontay Nov 13 at 19:12

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.