A Cryptic Riddle for Puzzlers

Happy as a Lark in a meadow,

Kind as a anonymous donor,

as Sunny and the midsummer's day,

Reliable as the sun rise that comes daily,

-Joe

Hint 1

You will have to do some cryptography.

Hint 2:

The cipher used is a simple substitution.

Hint 3

The cipher used is not a caesar cipher

• Why is this being downvoted again? Is it because of the rot13(ureevat)? – Cloudy7 Oct 10 '19 at 5:37

Sophia

which you find by

Taking the capital letters in the text ('HLKSRZ') and seing that as a Atbash ciphertext (i.e. $$A\leftrightarrow Z$$, $$B\leftrightarrow Y$$ $$\dots$$)

or

Make it Sophia-Lucy or Lucy-Sophia if you want to consider the red herring :) (If you take the italic letters in the plaintext, you get 'LUCY')

I've noticed that

there are four italicized letters which spell out "Lucy."

So, Joe wants to go to prom with

Lucy!

It's fairly simple, and I don't see any substitution here, unless I'm missing something.

• – WhatsUp Oct 8 '19 at 23:27
• @WhatsUp - Not my thoughts, exactly... :) – Voldemort's Wrath Oct 9 '19 at 0:04
• Sorry, I set that up. That is not the correct answer. There is some encryption involved. – Neo1009 Oct 9 '19 at 15:36
• @Neo1009 is it useful though, or just a red herring? – user62757 Oct 9 '19 at 16:36
• @Neo1009 - Unfortunately, hints don't count as part of the "actual puzzle." – Voldemort's Wrath Oct 9 '19 at 22:00