Mishearing 'Til Tuesday, I got crazy as icy shirts and the thing at hand induces fear. (4/2/5)
I think the answer is
This is scary
Mishearing 'Til Tuesday,
The band 'Til Tuesday had a single called "Voices Carry" in which one of the lines is
"Hush hush, keep it down now, voices carry"
often misheard as
"Hush hush, keep it down now, this is scary"
I got crazy as icy shirts
"as icy shirts" is an anagram of "this is scary"
the thing at hand induces fear.
The thing at hand is this, which induces fear (is scary).