17
$\begingroup$

Entry into Fortnightly Topic Challenge #38: Reusing Information 1

This puzzle sort of looks like a kakuro puzzle but there doesn't seem to be any sums. Figure out how this puzzle works and solve the kakuro.

Kakuro puzzle

Hint:

This puzzle is similar in concept to my Unusual Sudoku Puzzle involving three different puzzles.

Edit: Now I'm really mad at myself because I made another transcription error. I left out an 8 from the grid. The thing I was double checking against was missing it too. This time I can guarantee that it is solvable.

$\endgroup$
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Can you double-check the numbers around the outside for typos? (For instance, should the second-last row be (3, 1)?) $\endgroup$ – Deusovi Sep 15 '18 at 10:10
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Also, I suspect the next step is [rot13: gb fbyir n svyybzvab chmmyr hfvat gur hafunqrq pryyf nf tviraf], but that doesn't seem possible to me. I'm likely missing something, but would you check the puzzle on the off chance that I'm not? $\endgroup$ – Deusovi Sep 15 '18 at 10:15
  • $\begingroup$ Shoot, you're right. The second to last column should be (6, 2) $\endgroup$ – Bennett Bernardoni Sep 15 '18 at 11:33
  • $\begingroup$ @Deusovi It should be fixed now. I double checked the rest too $\endgroup$ – Bennett Bernardoni Sep 15 '18 at 11:38
  • $\begingroup$ @Deusovi turns out I had another error. I can now guarantee that it is correct if you want to try it again. $\endgroup$ – Bennett Bernardoni Sep 18 '18 at 5:03
7
$\begingroup$

Step 1

The grid can be solved as a Picross / Nonogram. The solution looks like this:
picross solution

Step 2

The unshaded cells form a Fillomino with this solution:
enter image description here

Step 3

From the Fillomino, we can add the cells together in each entry to figure out the clues.
enter image description here

And finally, the Kakuro can be solved using those clues:

enter image description here

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ (I admit that I didn't solve the Kakuro manually. I couldn't find a break-in anywhere, probably due to my lack of experience with the genre.) $\endgroup$ – Deusovi Sep 18 '18 at 5:28
  • $\begingroup$ For the longest time, I didn't know how you couldn't figure it out when you knew the hardest step. I knew I made the kakuro hard but not that hard. Then I realized I forgot a number... $\endgroup$ – Bennett Bernardoni Sep 18 '18 at 5:36
  • $\begingroup$ Anyway, I might post the logical solution to the kakuro as another answer, but that will have to wait for tomorrow as it is late here. I also have to admit, I probably made the kakuro a little too hard. Especially, when compared to the rest of the puzzle. $\endgroup$ – Bennett Bernardoni Sep 18 '18 at 5:41
  • $\begingroup$ @BennettBernardoni Yeah, it was surprisingly tough. I could narrow down a few cells, but never really got any farther than that - couldn't even get a single cell to start with! $\endgroup$ – Deusovi Sep 18 '18 at 5:42
  • $\begingroup$ I'd definitely be interested in seeing a logical solution, though. $\endgroup$ – Deusovi Sep 18 '18 at 5:45
2
$\begingroup$

As promised, here is the logical solution to the kakuro.

Let's start with notation for possible combinations to make things easier. 8(3): (1)25, (1)34 will mean the sum of 8 over 3 cells where one cell is known to be a 1 is 125 or 134.

The hardest part of the entire puzzle is finding the beginning. In this case, I made it really hard and in retrospect probably unfair especially with nothing to go off of. Anyway the start is at the bottom. If we add the bottom two rows and the green cells we should get the same result as the middle three columns and the blue cells. This gives us the following equation. $$39+24+G = 19+9+10+B \implies B-G = 25$$ This is a big number for the difference of two groups of four cells. In fact, the minimum for $G$ is $1+2+3+1=7$ and the maximum for $B$ is $9+8+7+8=32$ (note that the column 36 is 36(8): 12345678 which means that the repeated number can't be a 9). These values give are the intended difference as $32-7=25$. This allows us to fill in the repeated 1 and 8. We also know the 7 must go above the 8 since it can't be 8 or 9.

Kakuro1

We can rule out the 9 from the 23 column as the combinations are 23(6): 123458, 123467 and fill in the 8 and 9 in row 39. Continuing, row 39 is 39(6): 456(789) which leaves us with 456 in the middle cells.

Kakuro2

If we take the maximum numbers in column 19, we get $19-1-3-6=9$ left which goes in the last cell. Column 9 gives 9(3): 135, 234 as the remaining possibilities. The high number goes in the middle and low number goes in the top leaving the 3 for the bottom. We can complete row 24 with a 4 in column 10.

Kakuro3

We can finish column 10 as we already have a 4. This gives us column 9. Now let's shift focus to the left. Row 25 is 25(4): 1789 and we can determine where the 9 goes as column 14 is 14(4): 1238, 1247 with no 9. This leaves us with two possibilities for 7 and 8. Let's put one on top and the other on bottom. The 3 or 4 must be in row 18 as it is 18(3): 378, 468.

Kakuro4

We can reduce row 18 to two possibilities by eliminating from column 40. Row 15 also has two possibilities of 15(3): 168, 267.

Kakuro5

Now let's see if we can fill in row 36. 36 is 36(8): 12345678 or all but 9. Looking at column 40 (40(8): 12346789) 5 is not possible, 123 is already in the row, and 6789 is in the column. This leaves 4. Next, the far right is the only cell that can be 8. The 7 can only go in the far left and column 23. Column 23 is 23(6): 123458 which rules out the 7. Instead, 5 goes in this column. Which leaves 6 in column 36.

Kakuro6

Now back to the left. The top numbers are ruled out by the 7 in row 36. Row 36 is now 34(6): 13(6789) with 1 at the top and 3 below. Now we know the top of 40 is 132.

Kakuro7

Row 37 is 37(8): (123)45679. So, the end must be 5 then 4 with the middle three being a permutation of 679. Column 27 is 27(4): 37(8)9, 46(8)9. Both cases have a 9 which must go in row 14(3). Next, row 10 is 10(3): 127, 136 meaning that 6 or 7 goes in column 27. We can again split these possibilities to the top and bottom of the cell. We can then split both 14 rows to match.

Kakuro8

From here, we notice that the bottom row doesn't have a 3 in column 36. This forces the top row. Row 14(4) becomes 14(4): 12(4)7, 13(4)6, 23(4)5 giving 567 for the left cell. Moving to the top, column 23 is 23(3): 689 and row 13 is 13(4): (1)246. This makes the intersections 6.

Kakuro9

We can now eliminated the 6s from column 23 making 9 on the bottom and 8 in the middle. Column 14 is 14(3): 257 which gives 257 in that order. We now know the 4 and 6 in column 24 by their rows. Row 28 becomes 28(6): (1358)29, (1358)47.

Kakuro10

Column 24 is now 24(4): (46)59. A 2 goes in tow 28. Forcing a 4 in column 36 and a 1 in row 14(3). Then, 23 in column 23.

Kakuro11

We finish with a 31 in column 36. Yay! We're done.

Kakuro12

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.