Since it's Friday, and I'm really looking forward to the weekend, I've created yet another riddle for everyone to try and solve.

The Puzzle

I was in my chemistry class the other day, and I noticed something rather odd about the periodic table.

The New Periodic Table

I couldn't place my finger on it, yet I could see it clear as day. The professor stated that it was a new technology that he had created and it disproved a lot of the fundamental teachings for math and science. He stated that with the fundamentals of his technology, a basic math equation such as $4 + 6 = 10$ was now wrong. I asked how this could be, and he simply responded:

The very fabric of our knowledge is built on a lie that was established thousands of years ago.

How, seriously, how can this be correct? The lie that he speaks of has been proven over the course of these thousands of years.

Well, I decided to dive further into his periodic table, and couldn't find any of the essential building blocks such as hydrogen or helium. No matter how I did the math, I just couldn't do it. However, I was able to prove the following formulas true:

$4 + 20 = 61$

$13c + 6 = 36$

$15 + 4 = 12$

I was told there is another accurate formula that supports the professor's claims in his thesis, and that to find it I would have to solve a nested riddle which has also proven quite difficult.

The proof that you seek, is hidden in code; then scrambled again, the message unknown.

The key that you'll need, is hidden as well; seventy-seven minus all will tell.

Built on three, plus four you will see; the message that's hidden, not given, not free.

He gave me a piece of paper with a message scribbled on it; and told me to visit this website. He said that I shouldn't change the available mode options, but that the riddle above will tell me what to do. Here is the text:


He also said that he found another formula quite useful on his journey to creating this new technology, and said that it might prove to be useful to me:

$PL - P$

I'm not really sure what to make of it; hopefully you guys can help me out here. What is the professor's thesis, and what is the final formula that supports it? Also, what’s up with the weird expression he said would help?

Notes and Hints

I updated the message to be more fitting to a proper answer. For those who haven’t managed to decrypt yet, the unencrypted portions of the puzzle still apply. Just the encrypted portions have changed. I didn’t like the original answer as I thought it didn’t do the puzzle justice. The old version is still available in the edit history if you so choose.

Encryption Hint: The encryption method is difficult to figure out based on the minimal information given; however, once you find it you'll have one of those "ohhhhhhh okay" moments.

The message encrypted, electrical ties; would you like McChicken, or a burger with fries?

Key Hint: The key, similar to the encryption method is also difficult to find due to the nature of the riddle. I can tell you it is all lower case, and is more than one word!

The key you all need, is trapped within space; where it can seem hard, to keep up your pace.

Final Hint: Since there is already an answer that has made it to the final stages, I've decided to give one last hint to really help everyone.

The paragraphs start, after the art; include everything but math.


  • @user477343's comment in Rot13 is correct, also brought up this post.
    • The linked puzzle has no relation to this one.
  • @Hugh wondered if the duplication of elements was significant.
    • In response, the only significance is that one provides a correct answer, where the other does not. I used duplicated elements to throw people off.
  • @SteveV pointed out the duplication of column headers 3 and 10 being IIIA.
    • This is purely coincidence and has no significance. Also, great reference to 32, 18, and 17. I thought about using those in my puzzle but decided against it.
  • -

If you have any questions along your journey, feel free to ask; and as always, if you down-vote, please explain in a comment how I can improve my post.

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ I'm reminded of Little Alchemy :P $\endgroup$ – nikki Sep 15 '18 at 16:54
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ Also two columns are labeled III-A (3 and 10). clue or typo? off to spend more 32, 18, and 17. $\endgroup$ – SteveV Sep 15 '18 at 20:50
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ Duplication of element abbreviations and columns have nothing to do with the puzzle. If you can solve the riddle, you’ll under stand the final expression! :) I’m glad you’re all enjoying it! $\endgroup$ – PerpetualJ Sep 16 '18 at 17:30
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ I see nothing wrong with this periodic table $\endgroup$ – Quintec Sep 16 '18 at 18:22
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ This professor is not well... $\endgroup$ – T Dude Sep 17 '18 at 18:00

I think that

The Professor's theory is a lie

I got there by decrypting the code with these settings

Encryption Method: Arcfour (Arc from electricity, four from 4)
Encryption Key: zero gravity

This reveals a new challenge

Wkh sxccoh frqwdlqv wkh dqvzhuv, orrn ehbrqg wkh fkduw; wklv whfkqrorjb lv qrw frqwdlqhg, zlwklq wkh zrun ri duw. Vhyhudo qxpehuv jlyhq, wkh zrugv fdq vxuhob whoo; frxqw wkh vwduv, wklv surihvvru lvq’w zhoo.

Which can be solved by

A caesar cypher. PL (playdoh 42) - P (plaque 19) = 23, which is the cypher key

This reveals the final puzzle:

the puzzle contains the answers, look beyond the chart; this technology is not contained, within the work of art. several numbers given, the words can surely tell; count the stars, this professor isn’t well.

You can use these clues to

Get the 16th word of the first paragraph, 12th word of the 5th paragraph, etc.

Which reveals

The professor's thesis is a lie

Unless I messed up that last part, which is very likely

  • $\begingroup$ Rot13(Haqrefgbbq gur "ybbx orlbaq gur puneg" cneg, zrnavat gung cnentencuf fgneg pbhagvat nsgre gur gnoyr. Ubjrire, fgvyy qvqa'g trg ubj lbh bognvarq gur jbeq "gurbel" naq orlbaq gung, rfcrpvnyyl D11. Jnf gur ynfg cneg n jvyq thrff, nsgre nyy?) $\endgroup$ – Mark Sep 18 '18 at 19:14
  • $\begingroup$ This answer isn't 100% correct. Everything up to the final answer is. The final answer is only partially correct. Meant to up-vote, not mark as answer sorry. Also, rot13(D11 vf abg n jvyq thrff. V whfg fjvgpurq vg hc n ovg gb znxr gur nafjre n yvggyr zber qvssvphyg gb svaq.) $\endgroup$ – PerpetualJ Sep 18 '18 at 19:23
  • $\begingroup$ I was asking whether the last few words of T Dude's answer were a successful wild guess (since his answer was marked as a correct one at the time) :) As for your puzzle I'm sure it has a logical answer. $\endgroup$ – Mark Sep 18 '18 at 19:31
  • $\begingroup$ Hey Mark! Q11 (i think) refers to the quoted block 11th word. As for the sentence, I admit that I fudged some stuff.. couldn't get it to make sense otherwise. $\endgroup$ – T Dude Sep 18 '18 at 20:45
  • $\begingroup$ His final answer is the closest to correct so far; there is a bit of literal and lateral thinking required for the correct answer. Just don't overthink it. $\endgroup$ – PerpetualJ Sep 18 '18 at 20:47

A very cool puzzle.

Obviously the starting formulas are shown as a logic example: we can combine elements referenced by numbers to get other elements (numbers). Also now we know for sure that fire+air does not result in stains :)

Encryption method:

3+4, or electricity plus fire - since gravity is a hint for the key, could be Sun (or Star) After seeing another hint, "electrical ties" could also mean nuclear bond (wut). McChiken or a burger with fries could hint to fat(46), meat(48), crisps(23) or fire(4). UPD1: Arcfour = Arc(electricity)+four(fire). Its the encryption method. UPD2: not sure if accidental, but CBC(Cypher block chaining) looks just like chicken bacon and crisps.

Encryption key:

Gravity ( minus all?). After seeing the second hint, it only strengthens my suspicion of space bodies or processes involved here. UPD2: key = zero gravity... (tried a hundred more complicated keys, meh)

Another hint:

Not sure what it means, but possibly: Pl - P = Plastic (or Playdoh) - Paint = 56(or 42) - 28 = 28 (or 14, which is papier mache) UPD2: the encrypted message was also scrambled. Tested rot14, then noticed that P is also plague(19): 42-19= rot23, which unscrambled the message.

The last part:

"The puzzle contains the answers, look beyond the chart; Several numbers given, the words can surely tell" - ok, that seems to mean that we have to get words from paragraphs, starting from the paragraph right after the chart. Tried different paragraphs and ideas, but the only sensible result is "The professor's thesis (dive) (a)"... so there is something wrong with this approach. Also tried including the paragraph with formulas (4 + 20 = 61... etc), no luck so far. An interesting part is "count the stars, this professor isn’t well". The third paragraph has "hydrogen or helium", and there are other hints to stars in the puzzle. The whole theme is space, after all. Also, 11th word in the encrypted message is "technology".

  • 2
    $\begingroup$ These are some really good ideas and can be helpful in your search; however I'd like to point out that the puzzle requires both literal and lateral thinking. Your response to the hint of McChicken is way off, this requires lateral thinking. Keep up the good work! The next puzzle is more simplistic. $\endgroup$ – PerpetualJ Sep 18 '18 at 15:59
  • $\begingroup$ I had my suspicion about McChicken reference, but had to try approaching it lirerally. Thanks for another hint, though ;) $\endgroup$ – Mark Sep 18 '18 at 16:46
  • $\begingroup$ Good find, keep up the good work! $\endgroup$ – PerpetualJ Sep 18 '18 at 17:00

Partial Thoughts:

I have figured out the formulas you proved-

4+20=61 is Fire + Sand = Glass

13c+6=36 is Cold Water + Air = Snow

15+4=12 is Tobacco + Fire = Smoke

Also Built on 3 + 4 is built on fire and electricity.

  • $\begingroup$ Wouldn't $13c$ be a product and not a sum? Nice answer, nonetheless :P $\endgroup$ – user477343 Sep 17 '18 at 4:17
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ edited it, does this look better? $\endgroup$ – Shahriar Mahmud Sajid Sep 17 '18 at 4:19
  • $\begingroup$ Yeah, that makes more sense. I'm trying to solve the riddle and it is proving rather difficult... $\endgroup$ – user477343 Sep 17 '18 at 4:24
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Good job on proving the math! The idea for the encryption method is on the right track, but still a little off. Keep up the good work. $\endgroup$ – PerpetualJ Sep 17 '18 at 14:34

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.