# Do I need to guess from here on this sudoku?

I keep staring at this sudoku puzzle and can't seem to find the next move.

Is the next move a guessing move? I thought sudoku always has clear solutions, you just need to figure them out.

• I think your initial numbers are already wrong.. Jan 16, 2018 at 10:09
• Can you be more specific? I don't think I've made a mistake. My numbers are written in blue Jan 16, 2018 at 10:11
• It might be useful to update your image without the little hint/guess grey numbers, as they are confusing. E.g. the top right set of 9 squares has 2 squares with a little 4, and two with a little 7. Just keep the large black numbers (the starting ones) and the blue ones (your input). Jan 16, 2018 at 11:04
• @Adelin - thank you. I have been able to replay from the start to your current position, except for the 2/7/5 in column 1, and the 5 in column 2. Could you shed some light on how you arrived at those? R6C1 can be 2/5/7, R5C1 can be 2/5, and R7C1 and R6C2 can both be 5/7. Jan 16, 2018 at 11:31
• 5 is for sure in R6C1, dicatated by top middle 3x3 cell. There, you can have 8 and 3 exclusively in the R1 C4 respectively C5, which tells us that the remaining 1 and 5 are on R3, therefore telling us that the 5 in top left 3x3 cell is on C3 which, working togheter with the 5 from R8C6, cuts the bottom left 3x3 in such a way that 5 is only possible in R6C1. The remaining two (7 and 2) are easy Jan 16, 2018 at 11:42

## 2 Answers

No you shouldn't guess. The puzzle has a unique solution. However, you can't continue unless you calculate all possibilities. Once you do that, solving the puzzle will be easy. I have added the possibilities below. If you want to do that on your own, don't look down.

Once you do that, I think the next step is clear:

Note:

others pointed out in the comments that it is unclear why that particular cell cannot have a 5. To explain, in the red column there are 2 cells indicated in blue. They have two possibilities: (3,5). No matter how the possibilities are distributed, any of the cells will definitely have a 3 and the other a 5. Which makes it impossible for any other cell in that column to have a 3 or a 5.

Additional explanation (requested by the OP):

Why can't there be a 7 in the last row? Because it can only be in row 7.Explained below:

• How is it clear that in that place it's a 7? Why is it not a 5? Jan 16, 2018 at 10:53
• @Adelin if you look at thd possible numbers at that cell, you can see there is only a 7. What makes you think there should be a 5 Jan 16, 2018 at 11:00
• Jan 16, 2018 at 11:49
• Ah, that clarifies it. Thanks for the explanation. Jan 17, 2018 at 2:05
• The 7s in row 7 don't look right. 7 can't be the only possibility in two places in the same row/box. Your chart must be incomplete, or I'm misunderstanding something. Apr 13, 2020 at 19:47

For a start:

2,4 and 7 cannot be in the middle square bottom row, which means that there has to be 1 and 6.

This, in turn, means that:

the 8 must be in the top middle and that there must be a 5 to the middle left in the middle square, and so on.

• Welcome to Puzzling! This question already had an answer accepted 11 months ago - be sure to read other answers to make sure you aren't duplicating content.
– Deusovi
Dec 5, 2018 at 22:51