Finally came up with a story riddle. Hope it's okay for my first go.
A man walks up to this group of three, he says guess what I have and it's yours for free.
The group was intrigued, so they decided to play along. "Hi I'm Maya!" the girl exclaims as she grabs the box first straight out of his hands. She glances at his head and adds, "What's with the funny hat?", gesturing at his large black hat.
"The name is John Raprows, and the hat is special to me, we've been many a places together."
The second member shakes John's hand, apologizing for his friend and tells him, "The name is Hugo, but everyone calls me 'Ugo".
Before the strange man can finish his reply, the final of the three blurts out, "Hey hey, the name is Rick. What is it? Big box of cash? Diamonds?".
John turns to him and says, "Not all treasure is silver and gold mate. But trust me when I say, this box is better. I do warn you to be careful, because if you rush you'll be seein' stars before you even know what happened". And with that he turns and leaves, gone before anymore questions can be asked.
They all turn to each other and then glance at the box, which Maya is now realizing feels more like a shipping crate as she sets it down, her arms happy she let go of the weight.
Each person quickly made an observation about the box and saw that maybe this would not be so free.
- Rick pointed that the top of the box read, "For you three, and no other trio. Only together can you know what's inside. It will not require the whole of you three, but rather something unique to you each." Below that stated: "I will not open until you say both what is within and who it was that gave this gift to you".
- Ugo noticed on the sides were symbols. 1st a skeleton man and a monkey. 2nd is something that looks like a squid. 3rd is a crab, or rather many crabs. And 4th is what seems to be a fountain.
- Maya finally notices that there appears to be no way of opening it by force, so hopefully it opens when they guess correctly. She also lifts up the bottom of the box and notices a worn down message. All she can make out is: W__ _S T__ __M A___Y_ G__E?
What is in the box? Why must it be these three? And who is the man that gave it to them?
Bonus points if you get all the references on the box