Although I like this puzzle, I'm still fairly new to this site and I've never tried to write one like this before. I think it may be a little too long, a bit too easy and some of the spelling and/or wording may need tweaking. Consider me open to suggestions!

A man and his sons are traveling east to west across a desert in dizzying heat when they come to an oasis where a djinni, a marid and an oracle stand. The father asked permission for his sons to drink from the oasis and top up their water. The marid, the leader of the three, refused this request; but for his own amusement he offers a drink from the oasis and a single wish to be granted to any man who can, without any help from his companions, pass a test of wisdom, strength, skill or cunning in a manner of their choosing.

The father stood silently as his youngest son, perhaps the greatest archer that had ever lived, stepped forward. The oracle spoke the words "I have seen the outcome of every test and in only one could you win your wish". The archer proposes a challenge of archery, thinking that surely his greatest talent must be the test that can win him his wish. The marid said to the archer "Loose three arrows and if even one can touch my shadow from where you now stand you will have your wish." The archer stood for a moment shocked by his luck. He had surely been underestimated. He readied his first arrow and loosed at the shadow, ten yards or so away. A clattering was heard as two arrows fell to the ground away from the shadow. The djinni, who now held a bow, had struck the archer's arrow from the air with his own. After a moment of stunned silence, the archer lined up his next shot and waited, watching the djinni, who simply held his bow and a single arrow in either hand and did not move. The archer loosed his arrow and the djinni moved like lightning, and again two arrows clattered to the sands away from the shadow. The djinni lowered his bow, shrugged and turned away looking something between smug and bored. The archer who was quick on the draw took the advantage and loosed another arrow in a flash, before the djinni turned round, but again, like lightning the djinni flinched and two arrows clattered to the floor away from the shadow of the marid. "I must have chosen poorly" said the archer.

The second son, a wise cracking joker, stepped forward. The oracle spoke the words once more "I have seen the outcome of every test and in only one could you win your wish". The joker proposed a guessing game. The marid reached down, plucked a small mound of sand and placed it in his open palm. Then he said to the joker "Within three tries, guess correctly how many grains of sand are in my hand and you will have your wish." Three guesses the joker makes and each time the marid shakes his head. "I must have chosen poorly" said the joker.

The third and final son, a strong warrior, and steady as a rock, stepped forward. Again the oracle spoke the words "I have seen the outcome of every test and in only one could you win your wish". The warrior, proposes a test of strength and balance, for he was well suited to such tasks. The marid walked down the steep bank to the crystal clear oasis waters and filled a large wooden bowl right up to the brim. Then he said to the man "Within three tries, carry this bowl back up the bank to my companions without spilling a single drop and you will have your wish." Wasting no time, the warrior walked down the bank and assessed the bowl. He chose his stance and his grip and slowly began to lift. As he did, a trickle of water breached the edge and escaped to the sands. The marid shook his head and re-filled the bowl to his liking. Full of determination, the warior tried again, going even more slowly than before, and this time, he was able to lift the bowl to his chest, but as he took the first step, the water rocked and spilled a drop down onto the sand. The marid reset the bowl and the warrior stood thinking for a moment. He smiled as an idea popped into his head. He crouched by the bowl and positioned himself to sip at the water. "No!" said the marid. "You may not drink until you have completed the task." Though disappointed, with all his concentration and focus, he made his third attempt and was able to walk a few steps with barely a ripple appearing upon the water's surface, but as he climbed the bank a tiny slip on the sand sent a trickle over the edge and again the drops fell from the bowl to the sand. "I must have chosen poorly" said the warrior.

The father stepped forwards looking annoyed. He was old and in his age he had become slow and weak, and his senses dull, and yet now the oracle remained silent. "Let me face a test of teaching and I will win my wish." he said. "Very well." spoke the marid "Each man will be given one more chance at their test and each man must pass, and you may speak only a single word to each of them." The father stood silent for a few more moments before turning to his sons and speaking a the same, rather angry word three times. Then the sons began their tasks. The archer nocked and fired a single arrow and into the shadow of the marid it went; the joker made a single guess and his answer was correct; The warrior carefully carried the bowl of water up the bank without spilling a single drop.

What word did the father speak to his sons? And just for fun, what might his wish have been?

Also, a slightly bigger and shinier than usual +1 to whomever can tell me why the oracle says "in only one could you win your wish."

  • 2
    $\begingroup$ I thoroughly enjoyed this fable. The length did daunt me at first, but given how much I've enjoyed your other puzzles I decided to soldier on, and this one certainly didn't let me down. $\endgroup$
    – Inazuma
    Commented Jun 8, 2016 at 12:21

4 Answers 4


I think the word was


For the first son:

Wait until the shadow grows long enough that he is standing in it and fire. even if the arrow is deflected, it lands in the shadow.

Second son:

Wait as the wind blows the sand out of his hand, and when all is gone, answer "None"

Third son:

Wait until the water evaporates from the bowl...none has spilled! When the bowl is empty, then lift the bowl and carry it.

His wish?

I wished I had smarter, well-hydrated sons.

OP Answer

The word was "PATIENCE!" and the explanations above are spot on.

  • $\begingroup$ This isn't the exact word I wanted but you got the Idea and it's close enough, the explanations are spot on, and I like the wish. Accepted and +1 (but it isn't shiny) $\endgroup$ Commented Jun 8, 2016 at 11:35

My guess at the oracle's words meaning: He said that "in only one [test] could [they] win [their] wish" because of all tests, only their dad will pass his. And their dad is nice to his sons (see the beginning :

The father asked permission for his sons to drink from the oasis

Not for himself, for his sons). So following that logic he may wish that his sons' wishes come true. That is also part of why the Oracle says nothing to him, he can't just say "whelp, your wish will come true" (as it will most likely skew the prediction imo).

The other part being that he is the last one to pass a test and thus the one who will success. (here you could say that "every test" may be interpreted as the 4 tests that y'all pass today.)

There you go, I went a bit ahead of myself in the end but that's my guess.

  • $\begingroup$ Not what I had in mind. You get a +1 but it won't be very big or shiny. $\endgroup$ Commented Jun 8, 2016 at 16:07

I propose an answer only for the oracle's statement and to earn a big, shiny +1.

The sons...

Should have challenged the marid to a race swimming the oasis. Even if there is a rule set against drinking or filling their waterskins, all they would do is fail the test, but their thirst would be slaked by then anyhow.

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Not what I had in mind. Here's a small, unpolished +1 $\endgroup$ Commented Jun 9, 2016 at 4:27
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ *buffs it up and displays it proudly on the shelf anyway* $\endgroup$ Commented Jun 9, 2016 at 4:44
  • $\begingroup$ Just saying, but swimming in water actually steal your skin water ... $\endgroup$
    – user52327
    Commented Nov 9, 2018 at 15:47

The answer for the oracle's statement to earn a big shiny +1 is :

A test of patience. All the sons obviously needed to have patience to complete their tasks as mentioned by @IrishPanda.

  • $\begingroup$ You can comment on your own posts. $\endgroup$
    – Welz
    Commented Apr 15, 2018 at 18:10

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.