This puzzle is part of the Monthly Topic Challenge #3: Pencil and Paper Games

I'm a bit unsure who to ask about this...

You see, there's this guy I know. I say 'know' - we're not close mates, come from entirely different walks of life really. It's more that - for some reason I still don't fully understand - he seems to trust me, value my opinion... Because over the last ten years, he's contacted me several times when he's been going through some kind of personal difficulties - crisis of faith, relationship problems... that kind of thing. Except he doesn't tell me exactly what the problem is. No, it seems this guy has decided that the way to help him cope with his troubles is to play a game...

So each time, he gets in touch, we exchange correspondence, have a bit of back-and-forth, he invites me over after work, then we both drink rather too much and have a game of hangman - you know, the paper-and-pencil game? He chooses a secret word and I have to guess the letters from it. And I know everyone has their own slightly different way of drawing the gallows, etc., but in this guy's rules you effectively got ten chances to be wrong, and on the eleventh that was it - game over*. Sometimes he won, sometimes I won, and no matter what the outcome he'd thank me for helping him clear his head, said I'd "made his mind up for him", and then at the end of the night he'd send me on my way with a little something for my trouble, and I'd try to stagger home but always wake up in a ditch the next morning with a terrible hangover, very little recollection of the night before, and covered in goodness-knows-what. Happy days...

Well, the other day I received an initial message from him inviting me over for another game, but the strange thing is: since then I haven't heard a peep out of him. He's gone all cold, like - isn't answering my replies asking him when we should be meeting. I'm worried something might have happened to him.

For some reason I've kept all the old games of hangman we've played. I'm wondering if there might be some clues here to help me work out what's happened this time. Only thing is, because he likes his secrecy we always play in a code. Probably should have mentioned that sooner... Each letter of the alphabet is represented by a different symbol. Always the same code each time. Unfortunately, I don't have the key to hand. And I can't actually remember what the solutions were - like I say, we always drink A LOT while playing - only that I'm sure there was some kind of theme to them. I just wish I could recall what it was...

Can you help me? It might help you to know that I always play a particular strategy to my first guesses - one that a lot of players of the game use. And then I have another strategy for the next few guesses that I often resort to using... After that, it's just sensible guesswork.

I really hope he's okay.

TASK: Describe the narrator's hangman-solving strategy, deduce the five solutions to the previous games, and thus the identity of the 'guy' who instigates the games. What's happened this time?

Five Hangman games with symbols in place of letters

* Note from OP: This is the rule-set I always played when I was a kid: Five lines for the gallows (including the little strut to support the top-beam), then head, body, two legs, two arms. I know other people might use more or fewer lines in their construction, or do the arms before the legs, even sometimes adding feet or facial features if they want to give more chances (or extra struts at the bottom of the gallows if they value decent carpentry techniques and structures built to last...). In any case, I've stuck with what I know :)


1 Answer 1


I believe your partner is

King Henry VIII of England,

the words are

his wives' surnames (or equivalents thereof),

and the significance of your games is that

hanging signifies that he will have the wife in question executed rather than merely divorcing her or waiting for her to die.

The five words so far are


The sixth must have been


and the reason you have not heard from him is that

Catherine Parr outlived him

and therefore

your pastime with good company has come to an end.

Your initial strategy is to

guess the vowels in alphabetical order

but I'm afraid it isn't clear to me what your not-always-used second stage is, though it seems that your next guesses are quite often

S, R, N in that order. (I might have expected TNSHR, or something similar, on letter-frequency grounds, but for any variation on that theme your first guess after the vowels should be T and it clearly isn't.)

The words, along with your incorrect guesses, are:



we can see the initial vowel guesses and then the other things you've tried. I don't know what letter [ represents, though an obvious guess would be T.

He has indeed had

a "crisis of faith" (it was under him that the Church of England seceded from the Roman Catholic Church) and "relationship difficulties" (he had six wives and killed two of them).

In comments, JLee asks how I figured out which letter was which.

I was expecting the first step to be either "common letters, in order according to some widespread estimate of letter frequency" or "vowels, in alphabetical order". I looked to see what symbols consistently appeared in what order in the wrong guesses, and aside from not knowing what order > and * come in this was sufficient to determine the order of the first few symbols, and conveniently & comes out as probably O with either version of the first step. So then, looking at the first game, I asked Qat for words A-A-O-, E-E-O-, or T-T-O-, looking for things that might be one of a set. There weren't many plausible candidates (some very obscure words along with AMAZON, ANALOG, ARAGON, AVALON, and TATTOO), and after a moment it occurred to me that ARAGON is obviously one of a set, and after another moment that lots of other things in the question would make sense if that were the right first word. Then I checked that all the other games were consistent with my theory, and the names in those games gave me most of the other letters used in the games, the only exception being [.

  • $\begingroup$ +1, but maybe explain your logic of how you figured out which symbols are which letters? $\endgroup$
    – JLee
    Sep 22, 2022 at 5:14
  • 6
    $\begingroup$ @JLee Some explanation of the solving process now added (at the end of the answer). I am expecting you to upgrade your +1 to a +2 accordingly. $\endgroup$
    – Gareth McCaughan
    Sep 22, 2022 at 20:07
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ I hadn't quite noticed before rot13(gur ynpx bs qvirefvgl va Urael'f jvirf' anzrf. Unys bs gurz jrer pnyyrq Pngurevar. Zbfg bs gur erfg jrer pnyyrq Naar.) I suspect part of this is that rot13(gurer jnf whfg yrff qvirefvgl bs sberanzrf gura guna abj). Allegedly rot13(friragl creprag bs jbzra va Ryvmnorguna Ratynaq jrer pnyyrq Ryvmnorgu, Wbna, Znetnerg, Naar, Nyvpr, Ntarf, Znel, Wnar, be Xngurevar.) But rot13(1. vg fgvyy ybbxf nf vs ur unq n guvat sbe Pngurevarf naq 2. bar bs gur Xngurevarf naq bar bs gur Naar'f jrera'g npghnyyl sebz Ratynaq). $\endgroup$
    – Gareth McCaughan
    Sep 22, 2022 at 20:14
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Thx for the extra detail. It makes more sense now. I tried to give a 2nd upvote, but it undid my original upvote, so i put it back. So technically, i have now given you two upvotes, even if that means it is the same one twice. :) $\endgroup$
    – JLee
    Sep 22, 2022 at 21:50
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Ha! (I'm sure I don't need to say explicitly that I was only joking about the +2, for all the obvious reasons, but I am adding this parenthesis anyway because Stack Exchange doesn't allow comments that are very short.) $\endgroup$
    – Gareth McCaughan
    Sep 23, 2022 at 0:44

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.