OEEE
XOOX
EXEX
XEOE
Exactly one letter needs to be exchanged into one of the other two. But where and which one?
I intended this to be part of Monthly Topic Challenge. This is sort of a hint.
Puzzling Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for those who create, solve, and study puzzles. It only takes a minute to sign up.
Sign up to join this communityOEEE
XOOX
EXEX
XEOE
Exactly one letter needs to be exchanged into one of the other two. But where and which one?
I intended this to be part of Monthly Topic Challenge. This is sort of a hint.
I think it's
The 2nd E in the 3rd row, it needs to be an O
How come:
The whole grid looks like Tic-tac-toe on a 4x4 grid. Given there are 5 Xs and 4 Os, it should be O's turn to play. Playing in the 2nd empty (E) square in the 3rd row guarantees a win for the player with the Os, completing both a vertical 3 in a row and a diagonal one. $$ \begin{array}{cccc} \mathsf{\text{O}} & & & \\\mathsf{\text{X}}& \mathsf{\text{O}} & \mathsf{\text{O}} & \mathsf{\text{X}} \\ & \mathsf{\text{X}} & \color{lime}{\mathsf{\text{O}}} & \mathsf{\text{X}} \\ \mathsf{\text{X}}& & \mathsf{\text{O}} & \end{array}$$
Not sure if this is the intention, but
X is present in rows
2,3,4
and columns1,2,4
O is present in rows1,2,4
and columns1,2,3
E is present in rows1,3,4
and columns1,2,3,4
So
If the constraint is
present in 3 rows/columns
, the only way is to change the E in column 1 (all other columns have 2 Es). Can only be changed toX
to not break constraint for O.
E
perhaps representing "empty"
$\endgroup$
Aug 2 at 11:35
Is it
the 2nd E in the 4th row needs to be an O.
Reasoning:
Tic-tac-toe comes to mind. There are 5 X's, but just 4 O's, so it seems we need to change one of the E's to an O, but which one?
The X's form 3 rows of 2, where 2 of those rows are connected at one point. Therefore we must place the O so that that setup holds true for O's also. That means the O must replace one of the E's on the bottom row.
To decide which one, we notice the number of columns and rows taken up by X is 3, so in order to match that, the O must replace the E in the 2nd column.