16
$\begingroup$

Fifteen related guests visited a restaurant and got into an argument about who was the greatest among them. To settle the dispute, they asked the owner to decide.
He thought for a moment, then said “While you are eating, write down as many stars as you can name. After the meal I will tally the results.”
The guests finished their meal in peace, then handed in their work.
“So who is the greatest?” asked one.
“I dare not say; I fear another brawl. But I will send you each home with a word search puzzle. The one I chose is encoded within. And it’s not the one who named the most stars. That was a ploy to keep you occupied while you ate. To ensure you are far apart by the time you decode this, I have obfuscated your names. Tiny ladle may have named the most stars, but they are not necessarily the one I deem the greatest!”
“But there are only fifteen of us,” retorted one.
“Yes, to get you started, I added the name of my restaurant into the mix and highlighted it for you. See? ‘A star queue banded overhead’? That’s this restaurant, the Milky Way. As you can see, this is not a normal word search.”
“It’s jagged. But the letters are connected, right? Without doubling back on themselves or anything sneaky like that?”
“Certainly.”
“And you promise this reveals who you deem the greatest?”
“Yes, you all are hidden within. But once solved, one of you will stand out!”

Here is the list of participants the owner wrote down:

1 thousand stars – “Peace age sunshine dawns” (8)
2 thousand stars – “A star queue banded overhead” (8)
3 thousand stars – “Is thunderbolt carrier of Zeus” (6)
5 thousand stars – “Is a worthy foe on Hercules’ first labor” (3)
6 thousand stars – “The quick bunny hunter” (10)
7 thousand stars – “Vain queen is banished skyward” (10)
8 thousand stars – “Stings cause massive pain” (8)
10 thousand stars – “Is Orpheus’ extraordinary instrument” (4)
11 thousand stars – “These begin in May, exit June” (6)
12 thousand stars – “Sported golden fleece, once” (5)
14 thousand stars – “Bears a big copper pot on its back” (9)
15 thousand stars – “Hideous Typhon’s aquatic prey” (6)
18 thousand stars – “Mad Ford auto leaping with horn” (6)
19 thousand stars – “Dons stars as a girdle and bow” (5)
20 thousand stars – “Bird crossing up north” (6)
21 thousand stars – “A tiny dipper atop Claus’ home” (9)

Here is the word search the owner created:

word search

Text Version ('MILKY WAY' is highlighted in a jagged line)

MCEFAZSAUYJOCSLKYEPTURAB    
IEURISTQRAUQIJTIONIMRGEM  
NYRYJVEOUAAUFSYWIPRTTORI  
AWRGJIKORGINIULFEINMYSCY  
IUGCEXUQCNOVMBILMWLKPWAG  
OXLYTNEIAPISCESWORDEGGAJ  

Who was deemed the greatest and how do you know?

Hint:

If the guests are not in the traditional word search, what is?

Hint 2:

There are a few things in this puzzle which seem suspicious, unexpected, or unpleasing. Might they have a shared explanation? It can either be found directly or deduced. (If you find it, you could comment 'aha' and I'll stop giving hints to give you time to work the final stage).

Hint 3:

What do the star counts and clues look like?

Hint 4:

MJR

Hint 5:

MJR (3 words of instruction) are trivial to find, essentially in plain sight, so I'm running out of hints as to how to find them. Regarding the clues, the star counts and text is critical. For example, changing 'vain queen' to 'conceited lady' makes the puzzle unsolvable.

Hint 6:

MJR is found! Congrats @Elpharya! Now, what is "it"? Not what you probably think. Consider the entropy of this puzzle.

Hint 7:

MJR was just an optional hint (not critical to the solution), so it was intentionally quite easy to find. Now we get to the crux of the puzzle. Can you find a single, logical mechanism which rectifies various problematic/unsatisfactory aspects of this puzzle and also makes the word search solvable? You can use MJR as a guide, or search this puzzle as a whole for additional hints/observations.

Hint 8:

"This is not a normal word search."
"It's jagged."
Why did the guest say the puzzle was jagged? They were not referring to the 'Milky Way'. Think for example software programming or an old rug.

Hint 9:

Why are there gaps in the star counts? What goes in the gaps?

Hint 10:

Here is the top image search result I got for "merge jagged rows". Hopefully it will help? https://media.geeksforgeeks.org/wp-content/uploads/20200131134104/Jagged-Array.jpg (think of a solution that is simple, almost trivial, yet not immediately obvious)

Hint 11:

You stop at Scorpius' resort villa for a visit, and find the following scrap of paper lying outside their door. "Interesting," you muse, pocketing it.
clue

$\endgroup$
19
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ I see your point, no not scrambled, they will look just like the highlighted example or the other one that is rather conspicuous. $\endgroup$
    – Amoz
    Apr 22 at 16:24
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ I suspect the poorly worded/uninspiring clues and dense numbering would make a very unsatisfying crossword. $\endgroup$
    – Amoz
    May 16 at 14:45
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Rot13 (Zl svefg gubhtug jura ybbxvat ng gur pyhrf vf gung gurl’er pelcgvp pyhrf nf jryy nf abezny pyhrf, nf V frr znal jbeqf gung pbhyq or vaqvpngbef be ovgf naq cvrprf, ohg V unira’g orra noyr gb fbyir nal fb sne. Gurer vf cebonoyl fbzr bgure cebcregl bs gur pyhrf gung znxrf gur jrveq jbeqvat znxr frafr, ohg V qba’g xabj jung gung zvtug or. Nyy gur pyhrf ner cerggl fvzvyne va yratgu naq jbeq pbhag, fb gung zvtug zrna fbzrguvat nf jryy.) $\endgroup$
    – SeptaCube
    Jun 8 at 4:42
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @SeptaCube you are very close $\endgroup$
    – Amoz
    Jun 10 at 17:34
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ rot13(7. V nterr gung gur pyhrf ybbx n yvggyr nf vs gurl zvtug or pelcgvp pyhrf, ohg V gbb pna'g fbyir nal bs gurz vs fb; zber yvxryl vf gung gurl ybbx gung jnl orpnhfr gurl jrer jevggra haqre n pbafgenvag -- fhpu nf arrqvat gb sbez n jbeqfrnepu tevq be fbzrguvat. Vs gurl npghnyyl sbez gur erdhverq jbeqfrnepu fbzrubj, V nz vzcerffrq gung gurl qba'g ybbx zhpu jbefr guna gurl qb, rfcrpvnyyl nf gurl nyfb arrqrq gb pyhr tvira jbeqf. Creuncf gurl sbez bayl cneg bs gur jbeqfrnepu, naq gurer vf zber gb qb jvgu gur bevtvany tevq. Be creuncf guvf vfa'g ernyyl n jbeqfrnepu ng nyy.) $\endgroup$
    – Gareth McCaughan
    Jun 22 at 13:37
11
$\begingroup$

And it all becomes clear....

Looking at the most recent Hint 11, with what looks like a torn off wordsearch... but wait? The last line looks the same, but the ones above don't? actually they look familiar - 'a tiny d', 'bird'... They're the clues! So looking at the gaps, there's no clues for 4, 9, 16 and 17. So if we line up the hints as if they're in the wordsearch verbatim, and substituting the first line of the original wordsearch so it's now Row 4, and so on, we get a jagged wordsearch! [enter image description here

so this looks like something we can work with! We have enough of a picture that we can see a figure become clear - the constellation for Orion - apparently the greatest of the constellations. But what about Scorpius's note? Zeus (who doesn't seem to have a constellation himself) is the owner of the Milky Way restaurant and the creator of the puzzle :)

[enter image description here]

[enter image description here]

--clues--

1 thousand stars – “Peace age sunshine dawns” (8)

AQUARIUS

2 thousand stars – “A star queue banded overhead” (8)

Milky way - given in the question

3 thousand stars – “Is thunderbolt carrier of Zeus” (6)

AQUILA - provided by @El-Guest, represents the bird that carries Zeus's bolts

5 thousand stars – “Is a worthy foe on Hercules’ first labor” (3)

LEO - the first labor of Hercules is the slaying of the Nemean lion

6 thousand stars – “The quick bunny hunter” (10)

CANIS MAJOR/MINOR - provided by @xhienne, which is a dog

7 thousand stars – “Vain queen is banished skyward” (10)

CASSIOPEIA - a queen in greek mythology known for being vain

8 thousand stars – “Stings cause massive pain” (8)

SCORPIUS - scorpions have stingers

10 thousand stars – “Is Orpheus’ extraordinary instrument” (4)

LYRA - like a lyre

11 thousand stars – “These begin in May, exit June” (6)

GEMINI - zodiac sign for those born between date in may and june

12 thousand stars – “Sported golden fleece, once” (5)

ARIES - aka the ram

14 thousand stars – “Bears a big copper pot on its back” (9)

URSA MAJOR - punny with bear, and the copper pot referring to the big dipper

15 thousand stars – “Hideous Typhon’s aquatic prey” (6)

PISCES - a fish. Also visible on the last line of the wordsearch

18 thousand stars – “Mad Ford auto leaping with horn” (6)

TAURUS - the bull, also available as a Ford Taurus

19 thousand stars – “Dons stars as a girdle and bow” (5)

ORION - also known as the archer

20 thousand stars – “Bird crossing up north” (6)

CYGNUS - a constellation that appears as a bird

21 thousand stars – “A tiny dipper atop Claus’ home” (9)

URSA MINOR - the little dipper, appearing north (over Santa Claus' home)

$\endgroup$
12
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Amazing! rot13(Whcvgre) is probably wrong: it is not a six-letter word and it is neither a star nor a constellation. $\endgroup$
    – xhienne
    May 6 at 23:40
  • $\begingroup$ @xhienne thanks! You're totally right, I couldn't count for that one ha. I think with the new hint something else is missing in order to find the words in the search... $\endgroup$
    – Elpharya
    May 7 at 2:36
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ I was not able to find any name you found other than rot13(CVFPRF) in the word search. FOr “Is thunderbolt carrier of Zeus”, I initially thought it referred to the rot13(plpybcrf jub oebhtug gur guhaqreobyg gb Mrhf) but I wasn't able to match any of their names to a celestial body. For “The quick bunny hunter”, I think this is rot13(rvgure PNAVF ZVABE be PNAVF ZNWBE). $\endgroup$
    – xhienne
    May 7 at 10:37
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ @Elpharya I believe this is your missing six-letter thunderbolt carrier — you should now have all of the names at least!! $\endgroup$
    – El-Guest
    May 10 at 12:58
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ @El-Guest Thank you my El-friend! I'll add it in :) $\endgroup$
    – Elpharya
    May 10 at 13:07

This site is temporarily in read only mode and not accepting new answers.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .