6
$\begingroup$

This is the fourth entry in my decentralised or "Swiss" chess mini series. See bottom for a recap of the modified rules of Swiss chess.

Enough warm up! It is time for a proper Swiss chess problem:

Task:

Consider the Swiss KNN-K endgame: All pieces except for the two kings and two white knights have been traded and a neutral (no immediate threats on either side) position has been reached. In regular chess this is a theoretical draw: Assuming best play from both sides white despite being two pieces up cannot force check mate. But what about Swiss chess? Is the Swiss king + 2 Swiss knights vs Swiss king endgame winnable or a draw? Please back up your answer by summarising the successful side's strategy.

By "summarising" I mean: Give just one or two example variations demonstrating each major step the strategy may consist of. I'm not asking for an exhaustive search tree

Note: This may look rather daunting at first sight but Swiss rules actually make it much easier to analyse than the standard chess KNN vs K

Swiss chess primer:

In Swiss chess, the advantage in terms of mobility of a centrally placed piece over a piece in the corner is compensated for by opening up additional squares a marginalised piece has access to. This applies to all pieces except rooks and pawns. To keep rules simple, the queen like in standard chess is a bishop+rook even though that does mean it is a bit weaker on edge-of-the-board squares.

Credit to @AxiomaticSystem for the following streamlined description of Swiss moves:

  1. Movements ending at the starting square are implicitly forbidden

  2. The King may either take a diagonal step, or make an orthogonal jump. This jump can skip at most as many squares as the number of edges the King is on.

  3. A bonk is a unit move (knight leap for the Knight, diagonal step for the bishop), except if this move would take them to a square off the board, the piece moves to the closest on-board square instead.

  4. A Knight can always bonk. In addition, if it's in the corner, it can also take a diagonal step .

  5. A Bishop can always move as normal. If the number of possible normal moves (assuming otherwise empty board) is smaller than the maximum, 13, then the bishop can also bonk off the nearest edge. (If the Bishop is on one of the long diagonals there are two nearest edges and both are allowed.) This extension is, however, capped at 13 possible moves total, meaning that if necessary the longest bonk moves are pruned.

  6. The Queen moves like a Rook or Bishop.

Here are some animated gifs, showing the full set of legal moves from a representative set of squares for the Swiss knight, the Swiss bishop, the Swiss queen and the Swiss king. If you need more info, please comment or find some at the other Swiss chess posts.

enter image description here enter image description here

enter image description here enter image description here

Hint:

Note that due to the "asymmetric" way the Swiss king moves it is sometimes possible for a Swiss king to give check to the other Swiss king. Not very royal behaviour, admittedly, but useful to know.

$\endgroup$
2
  • $\begingroup$ Are you considering the option that it may not be possible to guarentee a checkmate? $\endgroup$
    – Ankit
    Mar 14 at 17:11
  • $\begingroup$ @Ankit As a theoretical possibility certainly, but I find it rather unlikely given the preliminary anaylsis I've done. Do you have reason to believe it is not possible? $\endgroup$ Mar 14 at 18:40
3
+250
$\begingroup$

General strategy:

Using the denser footprint of Swiss knights on the edge we can build this simple prison
enter image description here
which confines the defending king to a 12-square "L"-shaped area.
Please note how perfectly the shapes of the king's and knights' sets of allowed moves match on the edge where the knight has just enough to prevent the king from utilising his two-square jump.

How difficult is setting up such a prison?

Shouldn't be too difficult. We just need to get the white king to the centre. Depending on where the other pieces are we can choose and switch the most convenient corner for the prison by a single move of the king. For example, if the black king were in the top right corner then it would take just three moves Ke5, Nb8, Nh2 to relocate the prison to that corner.

Where from here?

Once the black king is cornered we can start closing in the walls by advancing the knights to a5 and e1. I assume there will be a way of forcing checkmate from this position.

A few checkmates:

Checkmate 1:

Checkmating a cornered king:
enter image description here

    1.   ...    Ka1-b2
    2. Kd4-c4   Kb2-a2
    3. Kc4-b4   Ka2-a1
    4. Na5-a4   Ka1-b1
    5. Kb4-c3   Kb1-a1
    6. Na4-b2+  Ka1-a2
    7. Ne1-c1#
 

enter image description here

Checkmate 2

Checkmating a careless king:
enter image description here

     1. Nh1-f1+  Kd1-c2
     2. Ng1-e1+  Kc2-c3
     3. Nf1-d1+  Kc3-d2?
     4. Ne1-c1   Kd2-c2
     5. Nd1-b1   Kc2-b2
     6. Ke5-d4   Kb2-c2
     7. Kd4-c4   Kc2-b2
     8. Kc4-b4   Kb2-c2
     9. Kb4-a5   Kc2-b2
    10. Ka5-a4   Kb2-c2
    11. Ka4-a2#
 

enter image description here

What a typical endgame may look like:

enter image description here

Step 1:

Claiming the centre for the white king:

    1. Ka1-b2   Kd4-d3
    2. Kb2-b3   Kd3-d4
    3. Kb3-b4   Kd4-d5
    4. Kb4-c3   Kd5-c6
    5. Nb7-a5+  Kc6-d5
    6. Kc3-d3   Kd5-e5
    7. Ng2-e1   Ke5-d5
    8. Ne1-f3   Kd5-c5
    9. Kd3-d4     ...
 

![enter image description here

Step 2:

The centred white king on his own leaves two wide and two narrow edges for the black king. We'll force the black king onto the narrow ones.

     9.  ...     Kc5-b5
    10. Na5-a3   Kb5-b4
    11. Na3-a1   Kb4-c3
    12. Nf3-g1   Kc3-c4
    13. Ng1-f1   Kc4-c3
    14. Nf1-d1+  Kc3-c4
    15. Nd1-b1   Kc4-c5
    16. Nb1-a2   Kc5-c4
    17. Na1-a3+  Kc4-c5
    18. Ke4-e5   Kc5-c6
    19. Na2-a4   Kc6-d7
    20. Na3-b5   Kd7-e7
    21. Nb5-d4   Ke7-f7
    22. Nd4-f3   Kf7-e7
    23. Nf3-h4   Ke7-d7
    24. Na4-a5   Kd7-c7
    25. Ke5-d5   Kc7-b6
    26. Na5-a4+  Kb6-c7
    27. Nh4-h6   Kc7-d7
    28. Nh6-g8
 

enter image description here
The prison is complete.

Step 3:

The writing is on the wall.

    28.   ...    Kd7-d8
    29. Na5-a7   Kd8-c7
    30. Ng8-e7    ...
 

and now
    30.   ...    Kc7-d7
    29. Na7-c8   Kd7-c7
    30. Ne7-d8    ...
 

followed by checkmate 2
or
    28.   ...    Kc7-b6
    29. Ne7-c6   Kb6-b7
    30. Nc6-b7   Kb7-c7
    31. Na7-a8#
 

$\endgroup$
2
  • $\begingroup$ Yes, very good start! The prison is indeed the main idea I had in mind. Would like a teeny bit more detail, though. How can we force the king into the prison and what does the actual checkmate look like? As I said in the post. A variation or two would go a long way. $\endgroup$ Mar 10 at 10:36
  • $\begingroup$ Nicely done. Formatting is a bit off, though (where is @bobble when you need them? ;-D), but I won't let that stand in the way of your bounty. Enjoy, and don't spend them all at once! $\endgroup$ Mar 15 at 22:31
3
$\begingroup$

This answer is incorrect. I'm just leaving it up here to show what my though process was.

My strategy was to start with checkmate and go backwards.
There are three positions of the black king we must consider:

  1. Black king in the center (not touching walls)

Not physically possible to checkmate just yet...
I say this be cause in order to checkmate, 9 squares must be controlled: The black king and the squares immediately surrounding it. It is not physically possible to control 9 the most is 8. white The king can usually do 3 but 4 if its in the corner. The knights can do 2 each. Below is a picture capturing 8, resulting in stalemate: Center

  1. Black king on the side (touching 1 wall)

It seems possible to checkmate the king. There are a checkmated position shown below: enter image description here However, notice that in this situation, there are 2 pieces checking the black king. This means the black king must have moved itself into check, which is illegal.
There for it is not possible to checkmate the king just yet.

  1. Black king in the corner (touching 2 walls)

Behold: the only checkmate positions: enter image description here The circled knights are options for the second knight. They all work. The problem is that to get the king there, the black king must have previously been on b8. This makes the white king unable to get to B6, and therefore renders this impossible.

Therefore

checkmate is impossible

$\endgroup$
10
  • $\begingroup$ I'm pretty sure your list off checkmates is incomplete, in fact, I'm missing the one I find most useful and without that at your disposal it might be difficult to win. The hint in the question may help you to find more. $\endgroup$ Mar 15 at 0:08
  • $\begingroup$ @Albert.Lang rot13(Ner lbh gnyxvat nobhg gur purpxzngr jvgu gur juvgr xvat va gur pbeare naq gur oynpx xvat ba gur fvqr? Orpnhfr gung jba'g jbex sbe gur fnzr ernfba nf bgure xvat ba gur fvqr purpxzngrf... gurer ner gjb cvrprf purpxzngvat vg.) $\endgroup$
    – Ankit
    Mar 15 at 0:23
  • $\begingroup$ Nope. I'll give you a hint. You are ruling out one of the cases too quickly. I can give you more hints if you like, so you can focus on the more interesting stuff but I don't want to spoiler it without warning. Your choice. $\endgroup$ Mar 15 at 0:34
  • $\begingroup$ @Albert.Lang Yeah I'm actually curious what I missed. I went back and tried again also n couldn't find anything. $\endgroup$
    – Ankit
    Mar 15 at 0:49
  • $\begingroup$ There is also at least one in case 2 which can be forced on a cornered black king. $\endgroup$ Mar 15 at 2:05
1
$\begingroup$

Not really an answer, but (in reaction to Ankid's post): I like the following endgame:

Black is almost cornered, and decides on Kh8, threatening h5.
After all even if white plays Ke7 black can escape to g6 after Kg8 Nh4h6. enter image description here

Alas checkmate 'off the borders' in 3

with Nh4h6 Kf8(forced) Nh6h7 Kf7(forced) Nh7h8.
(Regrettably I did not see a way to force winning like this.)

$\endgroup$
1
  • $\begingroup$ Nice! I also like 1. ... Kf8 2. Nh4-h6? stalemate. $\endgroup$ Mar 15 at 16:39

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.