Here is a pair of chess problems to kick off the new year. Your task is to solve both problems and work out what they have in common.

Left: Both sides cooperate to reach the position shown after White’s tenth move (starting from the usual position)

Right: Both sides cooperate to checkmate Black in two moves. Black moves first.

enter image description here

EDIT: This is for an on-going competition. If you have a solution, please refrain from posting until after 31st December 2020 midnight (it is probably wise to wait an extra day to account for time-zone differences since the site does not mention the time-zone)

Source: Andrew Buchanan, ChessBase India Christmas-New Year Solving 2020 (Left)

Source: Original (Right)


2 Answers 2


For the proof of game:

Model solution:

1.f4 Nc6 2.f5 Nb4 3.f6 Nxa2 4.fxg7 Nxc1 5.gxf8=B Nb3 6.Bxe7 Nxd2 7.Bh4 c6 8.Bf2 Qb6 9.e3 Qb3 10.Ne2 *


We'll count permutations later but first let's find actually different moves that can be used.
1. black can move their N through a6 instead of c6
2. white can do fxg7 xf8=B xe7 -h4 -f2 ("geh") or fxg7 xf8=B xe7 -c5 -f2 ("gec") or fxe7 xf8=B xg7 -d4 -f2 ("egd")


The white and black paths do not interfere; we can count them separately and multiply the results.
1. black: we have two submaneuvers: the 6 N moves and c6 Qb6 -b3. Qb3 must come last
1a. with Na6 we have 8-choose-2 = 28 ways of interleaving
1b. with Nc6 this reduces to 6-choose-2 = 15
2. white: also two submaneuvers: e3 Ne2 and the pawn promotion and return to f2
2a. "gec" and "egd": e3 -Ne2 must come last, therefore only 2 variations
2b. "geh" 10-choose-2 = 45 ways of interleaving

Grand total:

(28+15) x (45+1+1) = 2021

Happy new year!


For the helpmate, I think White can only mate by

promoting the g- or h-pawn to queen or rook, and removing the bishop on g8. This can be done in a couple of ways:
- first, Bg8-f7, -e6 or xd5 and then either of the four promotions (12 possibilities)
- first, h7-h8=R or =Q and then Bg8-f7, -e6, xd5 or -h7 (8 possibilities)

Black should not be able to

interpose something on the 8th line, which can be arranged by either
- blocking the c-file with Bb1-a2-c4 or Ng4-e3/e5-c4 (to c6 doesn't help of course) (3 possibilities) - moving both rooks from the c-file; there are seven files to choose from for both rooks, and we can either move Rc3 or Rc2 first, so that's 7x7x2 = 98 possibilities.

Together, this yields

(98 + 3) x (12 + 8) = 2020 possible helpmates.

So given that this is a New Year puzzle, there might be one that I'm missing, and @Sid found the last one:

1. Rc8 Bb8 2. Rxb8 Ra5#

which makes 2021 helpmates, exactly the amount of proof games. So that's what they have in common.

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ I think White can also mate by: ...Rc8 Bb8 Rxb8 Ra5# (if I am not wrong). So, that would make it 21 possibilities $\endgroup$
    – Sid
    Commented Jan 2, 2021 at 20:12
  • $\begingroup$ @Glorfindel the answer is correct, but the conventional notation for helpmates is 1. Rc8 Bb8 2. Rxb8 Rxa5# instead of 1 ... Rc8 2. Rb8 Rxb8 3. Rxa5#. Well done :) $\endgroup$
    – happystar
    Commented Jan 2, 2021 at 22:07

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.