This is the fourth Chain Puzzle in the Tabletop Games series, in which all puzzles are themed around board games, card games, tile games, and the like. The answer to this puzzle is a thematic word or phrase. The solver whose answer is awarded the green checkmark has first refusal on the opportunity to create the next puzzle in the series, which must somehow incorporate the answer to this puzzle somewhere within its construction. The solver is under no obligation to create the next puzzle - in the event that the solver does not wish to take up this opportunity, the puzzle's setter may take up the offer of a willing substitute setter or choose to continue the chain themselves.

Six guests, Miss Scarlet, Mr. Green, Colonel Mustard, Professor Plum, Mrs. Peacock and Mrs. White were invited to a party hosted by Mr. Black in his mansion. You're a detective that has to solve the murder case which occurred during this party, or shall I say, the murder cases? All of the people who participated at this party are dead, including Mr. Black.

There are multiple oddities scattered around the mansion. It's almost as if the killer wants us to find out what exactly happened! Which is why we can secretly assume for the sake of this puzzle that there was only one killer, and that killer was one of the people mentioned above (which also means they killed themselves at the end of it).

Your job is to find out

  1. Who the killer was
  2. Why the murderer killed each person individually, including themselves (there's a different motive for each).
  3. Which weapon was used to kill each person individually, excluding themselves.

and ultimately

Which game the killer wants you to play at your next game night!

Here are the case files:

Colonel Mustard was found dead in the hall. Beside him, an oddly arranged set of weights lied on the floor (shown below), accompanied by a note that reads My choice of weapon was easy for this one: Take an australian piece of wool and ship it to a country in Europe.
enter image description here

Mrs. White was found dead in the conservatory, accompanied with a note that reads OXXXOXXXOXOXOXOXOOXXOOXOXOXOXOOXOOOXXXOXOXOOXOOOXOO and a further note that reads I always noticed her looking at me. Oh, which weapon? The one which hasn't been used yet :)

Mr. Black was found dead in the library. He appeared to be reading a book called "Army N", accompanied with note that reads I twisted and moved this xenophobic, vain, irritating idiot down the drain with guidance.

Mrs. Peacock was found dead in the ball room, accompanied by a note reading IXCRAJEOUWBYFLPHNSZQMKTDGV and a further note that reads She died due to a logical conclusion

Fixed error above in edit - Was mostly cosmetic

Miss Scarlet was found dead in the lounge. There was simply a note reading She didn't feel like it, but I didn't either, so I made her do it.

Professor Plum was found dead in the dining room. An odd arrangement of bottle caps were placed on the table (shown below), accompanied by a note that reads That monkey was really enjoying nasty christmas ham.
enter image description here

Mr. Green was found dead in the billiard room. A small table seems to display an ongoing game of Blackjack (shown below), accompanied by a note that reads I let him play a better game with higher stakes.
enter image description here

Chain Puzzles are a novel approach to puzzle series creation, in which the solver of the previous puzzle in the chain becomes the setter of the next.

The answer to the previous puzzle (which provided the theme for this one) was:


  • $\begingroup$ think you mean *xenophobic? $\endgroup$ – matt Oct 26 at 19:03
  • $\begingroup$ @matt Yeah that was a typo. Thanks for pointing it out $\endgroup$ – Lukas Rotter Oct 26 at 19:05

Case Number: TG04

Report prepared by: Chief Inspector Stiv (PSE Police)

Personnel: This perplexing case was investigated - and solved - by a team of crack sleuths in the Chain Puzzles chatroom. Contributions are acknowledged where credit is due, with a particular hat-tip to Sergeant Braegh, whose keen eye and perceptive mind were incredibly useful on multiple occasions.

Background: Call at 7:30am from local postman. Seven bodies discovered at the mansion of Mr Black, suspected typical sextuple-murder-suicide (sadly rather common round these parts these days).

Findings: (in approximate solving order)

Professor Plum

We began our investigations in the dining room. While I examined the body, which was lying in a pool of blood on the floor, Sergeant Braegh observed that a quantity of bottle caps had been arranged on the nearby table in a specific pattern. "It's Braille," said he, "and it spells GLUTTON."

This was not welcome news, as a hypothesis immediately presented itself to me. "Egad!" I exclaimed to the Sergeant. "If I'm not much mistaken, this could be another 'Seven Deadly Sins' copycat crime. I suspect we may shortly find that all of the victims have some connection to specific Deadly Sins." (Namely: Envy, Gluttony, Greed, Lust, Pride, Sloth and Wrath.)

"I suspect you might be right, Inspector," said Sergeant Braegh. "And I've found the murder weapon." Carefully, the Sergeant produced a WRENCH from inside a nearby pot plant. His suspicions had been drawn by the mention of the word 'monkey' in the note found beside the body, and further corroborated by noting that the initial letters of 'was really enjoying nasty christmas ham' spelled 'wrench'...

Colonel Mustard

We moved into the hall. Another body lay surrounded by blood - that of the Colonel, an old colleague of mine from my military days. Not far from his body lay a selection of gym weights, whose arrangement seemed far from accidental. Once you've worked in the military, you never forget Morse code, and it was clear to me that the sequence of weights and bars spelled out '.-.. ..- ... -' or LUST to the layman.

Without wishing to disturb the scene before Forensics arrived, I observed the body from several angles until I eventually spotted a stab wound. The poor Colonel had been killed with a DAGGER, indicated within the nearby note by clues to DAG (an Australian farming slang term for excrement-covered wool) and GER, for 'Germany'.

Mr Green

The door to an adjacent room was open and we passed through, finding ourselves in the billiard room. The body of the disgraced former reverend was slumped beside an unfinished game of cards. I examined them for clues and once more found a craftily concealed message...

The values of the upturned cards among the four pairs were 7, 18 (King + 8), 5 (2 + 3) and 4 (A1 + 3). What's more, while the other cards were each accompanied by a single face-down card or betting chip, the 2-3 pair were next to two chips. Knowing that if A=1 and B=2 etc. these numbers could be converted using their positions in the alphabet to G, R, E and D, the use of the double-chip meant that two E's were required. Altogether, this spelled GREED.

(I also noted a crafty red herring - if the Ace were instead to be valued as 11 (its other possible value in blackjack), the 4 would become 14, the equivalent of 'N', thereby spelling 'GREEN', the name of the murdered man, instead...)

"He's been shot, sir," came Sergeant Braegh's voice from over my shoulder. "There's a REVOLVER. I suspect the note's remarks about 'a game with higher stakes' implies that Mr Green lost a game of Russian roulette."

Mr Black

Proceeding into the library, we found a fourth body, this one clearly bludgeoned with a blunt instrument of some kind. Picking up the note that lay upon his book, I spotted an unusual frequency of initial letters that were also Roman numerals - the inclusion of the phrase 'xenophobic, vain, irritating idiot' appeared to be noteworthy, representing as it did the Roman numerals 'XVII' for the number 17.

I made a remark to this effect and Sergeant Braegh made the natty observation that the title of Mr Black's book - 'ARMY N' when translated by a Caesar shift of 17 became the letters 'RIDP E', an anagram of PRIDE!

What's more, the Sergeant proceeded to locate the murder weapon concealed among the bookshelves - a piece of LEAD PIPING, as he had apparently suspected by duly noting that the use of 'down the drain with guidance' in the note clued the words 'PIPING' ('down the drain') and 'LEAD' ('guidance'), albeit with the latter pronounced differently.

Miss Scarlet

The body of Miss Scarlet was discovered in the lounge. The note beside her ("She didn't feel like it, but I didn't either, so I made her do it.") explained everything, with the Sergeant and I in agreement on the details - that the murderer had taken Miss Scarlet's life for reasons of SLOTH ('didn't feel like it'), and that it was under duress that the unfortunate Miss Scarlet had been forced to hang herself ('I made her do it') using the ROPE around her neck. It was not a pretty sight.

Mrs White

Stepping into the conservatory, we found the body of Mrs White sprawled upon the cold tiles, her head caved in with a CANDLESTICK - the only weapon outstanding from the weapon set in a game of Clue(do) ('The one which hasn't been used yet'). After a little thought, I managed to decode the note beside her body, noticing that at 51 characters long the message could be arranged into a 3x17 block. Upon so doing, the message became clear:

enter image description here

There amongst the O's, the pattern traced out by the X's could clearly be seen to spell the word 'ENVY'.

Mrs Peacock

We knew by now what remained - of the Seven Deadly Sins, the only one we had not yet encountered was WRATH. Yet, of course, we had been encountering it throughout the investigation! Every single one of these murders had been committed out of wrath, out of anger, rage, fury - call it what you will. And upon arriving in the ballroom, we found the body of our murderer, Mrs Peacock.

It was easy to deduce that having committed these horrific crimes in a haze of puritanical fire, Mrs Peacock had taken her own life out of remorse - 'a logical conclusion' indeed. And there, in her hand, one final note - 26 letters long, none repeating. I recognised it for a key to a code, and sure enough it helped us to decode one last message...

The murderer's final message


The evidence of our police doctor put the times of death in the following order: Mustard, White, Black, Peacock, Scarlet, Plum, then Green, suggesting that many of the victims did not finally breathe their last breath until after their villainous murderer. Certainly this is the order that has been repeated ever since in newspaper reports and articles. By considering the Deadly Sins for which these people had lost their lives in the same order, this gave us the sequence Lust, Envy, Pride, Wrath, Sloth, Gluttony, Greed. Taking their initial letters produced the codeword LEPWSGG.

By aligning the 26 letters of the note with the letters of the alphabet A to Z and reading off the letters from the note which corresponded to the letters of this codeword, I was able to decode Mrs Peacock's final, disturbing message...



All of this murder, all this violence, this cruelty, this unnecessary loss of life.. for a dice game?! Who can fathom the twisted machinations of a mind so bitter and warped? We do not yet know where this dice game is due to be played, who is to be involved, and what is at stake, but as soon as this report is filed I guarantee you one thing - I'll be on the case...

Report signed by:

╔═ ═╦═ ╦ ║ ║
╚╗  ║  ║ ║ ║
═╝  ║  ╩  ║
| improve this answer | |
  • 8
    $\begingroup$ Absolutely brilliant! You can be sure this answer will be rewarded with a bounty later on! :) $\endgroup$ – Lukas Rotter Oct 27 at 0:18
  • $\begingroup$ Thanks @LukasRotter - the puzzle totally deserved a write-up like this. It's the closest thing to an escape room I've seen on PSE! $\endgroup$ – Stiv Oct 27 at 8:33
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Could you please spell out for less fortunate of us, who cannot figure out why ROT13(ebcr) and why ROT13(PNAQYRFGVPX)? $\endgroup$ – Andrew Savinykh Oct 27 at 8:58
  • $\begingroup$ @AndrewSavinykh Sure - put it this way: we know that we have two weapons remaining for the last 3 deaths - the ROPE and the CANDLESTICK. Miss Scarlet's note reads like she was made to kill herself with one of these weapons. Now, I don't know about you, but to my mind it would be easier to kill oneself with hanging by rope than by self-bludgeoning with a candlestick! (Yes, I'm sure we can think up some strange 'Jonathan Creek' type scenarios...!) On the basis of probability, this linked Scarlet's death to the rope, leaving 'the one which hasn't been used yet' as the candlestick for White :) $\endgroup$ – Stiv Oct 27 at 9:18
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @AndrewSavinykh No worries :) You're right, no weapon list was given - but we can work them out... Instruction #3 read "Which weapon was used to kill each person individually, excluding themselves." This means we're looking for 6 weapons total (we don't need the one for the murderer themselves - and specifically we are told "they killed themselves at the end of it" in the brief). As the first 4 weapons discovered are all weapons from Clue(do) - which is the theme of the whole puzzle - it makes sense that the last 2 should be the missing weapons from the game, i.e. the ROPE and CANDLESTICK. $\endgroup$ – Stiv Oct 27 at 18:45

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.