The obvious solution to the first section (4 verses) is
CAT (neat, licks, lies at your feet purring; lions roar, cats chase shadows and watch over sleeping humans; may fly into a rage if treated badly and lash out at anyone).
The obvious solution to the second section (3 verses) is
RIDDLE (neat, fun to guess, warms the heart; sometimes hated, downvoted, commented on, and closed).
Now putting these together, I wonder if we should use the fact that
CAT is the subject of a long-running RIDDLERS' meme here on PSE, often associated with riddles whose titles contain the word "pray":
You will have to pray!You will have to pray!
riddle - pray you can find the word!riddle - pray you can find the word!
Riddle... pray that this is the last oneRiddle... pray that this is the last one
So perhaps the real intended answer is
PRAY.