Skip to main content
Added the clause(if the word asked in the question to the wise man was **ca**) to the last statement of the solution to be more clear
Source Link
G.One
  • 333
  • 2
  • 10

Question to be asked = "If I ask you if this is the correct path to go, would you say ça" ? 4 possibilities:

ca = yes
path' correctness = yes
reply= yes (ca)

ca = yes
path' correctness = no
reply= no (ga)

ca = no
path' correctness = yes
reply= no (ca)

ca = no
path' correctness = no
reply= yes (ga)

Hence we see whenever reply is ga the path is incorrect, if the word asked in the question to the wise man was ca .

Question to be asked = "If I ask you if this is the correct path to go, would you say ça" ? 4 possibilities:

ca = yes
path' correctness = yes
reply= yes (ca)

ca = yes
path' correctness = no
reply= no (ga)

ca = no
path' correctness = yes
reply= no (ca)

ca = no
path' correctness = no
reply= yes (ga)

Hence we see whenever reply is ga the path is incorrect.

Question to be asked = "If I ask you if this is the correct path to go, would you say ça" ? 4 possibilities:

ca = yes
path' correctness = yes
reply= yes (ca)

ca = yes
path' correctness = no
reply= no (ga)

ca = no
path' correctness = yes
reply= no (ca)

ca = no
path' correctness = no
reply= yes (ga)

Hence we see whenever reply is ga the path is incorrect, if the word asked in the question to the wise man was ca .

Source Link
G.One
  • 333
  • 2
  • 10

Question to be asked = "If I ask you if this is the correct path to go, would you say ça" ? 4 possibilities:

ca = yes
path' correctness = yes
reply= yes (ca)

ca = yes
path' correctness = no
reply= no (ga)

ca = no
path' correctness = yes
reply= no (ca)

ca = no
path' correctness = no
reply= yes (ga)

Hence we see whenever reply is ga the path is incorrect.