Skip to main content
added 1575 characters in body
Source Link
Toffee
  • 1.2k
  • 5
  • 13

A very neat puzzle! I felt like I needed to deduce and use a range of lemmas and corollaires to solve it.

Before we dive in, a couple of lemmas/corollaries:

Lemma 1: Consider the pattern:
lemma 1
We must have A > D

Corollaries: A cannot be 1 and D cannot be 6

Lemma 2: Consider the pattern:
lemma 2
We must have A+B = D+E

Armed with Lemma 1 we get:

step 1

Applying our corollary to column 3 forces

The 2 in R6C3 with some more cells coming as a result of lemma 1
step 2

Now

To ensure the horizontal bar is in the correct place in column 2, the 3 must be placed in R5C2
step 3

This forces

Row 3 into this unique arrangement with respect to the vertical bar
step 4

This is where we bring in lemma 2

R2C3 must be one more than R5C3. The only consecutive pair of numbers that fit are 4 and 5
step 5

Let’s go back to lemma 1 to get

step 6

Now

The 6 in row 5 can only go in one place to ensure the horizontal bar is in the correct place. This gives a lot more cells via the usual Latin square logic.
step 7

Finally, using lemma 2

In row 4 forces the final unique solution (which I slipped up on in my original submission - thanks Dante)
solution

A very neat puzzle! I felt like I needed to deduce and use a range of lemmas and corollaires to solve it.

Before we dive in, a couple of lemmas/corollaries:

Lemma 1: Consider the pattern:
lemma 1
We must have A > D

Corollaries: A cannot be 1 and D cannot be 6

Lemma 2: Consider the pattern:
lemma 2
We must have A+B = D+E

Armed with Lemma 1 we get:

step 1

Applying our corollary to column 3 forces

The 2 in R6C3 with some more cells coming as a result of lemma 1
step 2

Now

To ensure the horizontal bar is in the correct place in column 2, the 3 must be placed in R5C2
step 3

This forces

Row 3 into this unique arrangement with respect to the vertical bar
step 4

This is where we bring in lemma 2

R2C3 must be one more than R5C3. The only consecutive pair of numbers that fit are 4 and 5
step 5

Let’s go back to lemma 1 to get

step 6

Now

The 6 in row 5 can only go in one place to ensure the horizontal bar is in the correct place. This gives a lot more cells via the usual Latin square logic.
step 7

Finally, using lemma 2

In row 4 forces the final unique solution (which I slipped up on in my original submission - thanks Dante)
solution

A very neat puzzle! Before we dive in, a couple of lemmas/corollaries:

Lemma 1: Consider the pattern:
lemma 1
We must have A > D

Corollaries: A cannot be 1 and D cannot be 6

Lemma 2: Consider the pattern:
lemma 2
We must have A+B = D+E

Armed with Lemma 1 we get:

step 1

Applying our corollary to column 3 forces

The 2 in R6C3 with some more cells coming as a result of lemma 1
step 2

Now

To ensure the horizontal bar is in the correct place in column 2, the 3 must be placed in R5C2
step 3

This forces

Row 3 into this unique arrangement with respect to the vertical bar
step 4

This is where we bring in lemma 2

R2C3 must be one more than R5C3. The only consecutive pair of numbers that fit are 4 and 5
step 5

Let’s go back to lemma 1 to get

step 6

Now

The 6 in row 5 can only go in one place to ensure the horizontal bar is in the correct place. This gives a lot more cells via the usual Latin square logic.
step 7

Finally, using lemma 2

In row 4 forces the final unique solution (which I slipped up on in my original submission - thanks Dante)
solution

added 1575 characters in body
Source Link
Toffee
  • 1.2k
  • 5
  • 13

A very neat puzzle! I felt like I needed to deduce and use a range of lemmas and corollaires to solve it.

Before we dive in, a couple of lemmas/corollaries:

Lemma 1: Consider Consider the pattern:
lemma 1
We must have A-B (- is a grey bar, _ is and number). We must have A > B
Corollaries: 1-
_ > D

Corollaries: A cannot be 1 and _-6 are impossible configurations
Lemma 2: Consider the pattern --
. The leftmost two numbersD cannot be 6

Lemma 2: Consider the pattern:
lemma 2
We must have the same sum as the rightmost 2 numbersA+B = D+E

Armed with Lemma 1 we get:

step 1

Applying our corollary to column 3 forces

The 2 in R6C3 with some more cells coming as a result of lemma 1
step 2

Now

To ensure the horizontal bar is in the correct place in column 2, the 3 must be placed in R5C2
step 3

This forces

Row 3 into this unique arrangement with respect to the vertical bar
step 4

This is where we bring in lemma 2

R2C3 must be one more than R5C3. The only consecutive pair of numbers that fit are 4 and 5
step 5

Let’s go back to lemma 1 to get

step 6

Now

The 6 in row 5 can only go in one place to ensure the horizontal bar is in the correct place. This gives a lot more cells via the usual Latin square logic.
step 7

Finally, using lemma 2

In row 4 forces the final unique solution (which I slipped up on in my original submission - thanks Dante)
solution

A very neat puzzle! I felt like I needed to deduce and use a range of lemmas and corollaires to solve it.

Before we dive in, a couple of lemmas/corollaries:

Lemma 1: Consider the pattern A-B (- is a grey bar, _ is and number). We must have A > B
Corollaries: 1-
_ and _-6 are impossible configurations
Lemma 2: Consider the pattern --
. The leftmost two numbers must have the same sum as the rightmost 2 numbers

Armed with Lemma 1 we get:

step 1

Applying our corollary to column 3 forces

The 2 in R6C3 with some more cells coming as a result of lemma 1
step 2

Now

To ensure the horizontal bar is in the correct place in column 2, the 3 must be placed in R5C2
step 3

This forces

Row 3 into this unique arrangement with respect to the vertical bar
step 4

This is where we bring in lemma 2

R2C3 must be one more than R5C3. The only consecutive pair of numbers that fit are 4 and 5
step 5

Let’s go back to lemma 1 to get

step 6

Now

The 6 in row 5 can only go in one place to ensure the horizontal bar is in the correct place. This gives a lot more cells via the usual Latin square logic.
step 7

Finally, using lemma 2

In row 4 forces the final unique solution (which I slipped up on in my original submission - thanks Dante)
solution

A very neat puzzle! I felt like I needed to deduce and use a range of lemmas and corollaires to solve it.

Before we dive in, a couple of lemmas/corollaries:

Lemma 1: Consider the pattern:
lemma 1
We must have A > D

Corollaries: A cannot be 1 and D cannot be 6

Lemma 2: Consider the pattern:
lemma 2
We must have A+B = D+E

Armed with Lemma 1 we get:

step 1

Applying our corollary to column 3 forces

The 2 in R6C3 with some more cells coming as a result of lemma 1
step 2

Now

To ensure the horizontal bar is in the correct place in column 2, the 3 must be placed in R5C2
step 3

This forces

Row 3 into this unique arrangement with respect to the vertical bar
step 4

This is where we bring in lemma 2

R2C3 must be one more than R5C3. The only consecutive pair of numbers that fit are 4 and 5
step 5

Let’s go back to lemma 1 to get

step 6

Now

The 6 in row 5 can only go in one place to ensure the horizontal bar is in the correct place. This gives a lot more cells via the usual Latin square logic.
step 7

Finally, using lemma 2

In row 4 forces the final unique solution (which I slipped up on in my original submission - thanks Dante)
solution

added 1575 characters in body
Source Link
Toffee
  • 1.2k
  • 5
  • 13

A very neat puzzle! I felt like I needed to deduce and use a range of lemmas and corollaires to solve it.

I’ll try and narrow down the solve path and add itBefore we dive in, a couple of lemmas/corollaries:

Lemma 1: Consider the pattern A-B (- is a grey bar, _ is and number). We must have A > B
Corollaries: 1-
_ and _-6 are impossible configurations
Lemma 2: Consider the pattern --
. The leftmost two numbers must have the same sum as the rightmost 2 numbers

Armed with Lemma 1 we get:

step 1

Applying our corollary to my solution.column 3 forces

The 2 in R6C3 with some more cells coming as a result of lemma 1
step 2

Now

To ensure the horizontal bar is in the correct place in column 2, the 3 must be placed in R5C2
step 3

This forces

Row 3 into this unique arrangement with respect to the vertical bar
step 4

This is where we bring in lemma 2

R2C3 must be one more than R5C3. The only consecutive pair of numbers that fit are 4 and 5
step 5

Let’s go back to lemma 1 to get

step 6

Now

The 6 in row 5 can only go in one place to ensure the horizontal bar is in the correct place. This gives a lot more cells via the usual Latin square logic.
step 7

Finally, using lemma 2

In row 4 forces the final unique solution (which I slipped up on in my original submission - thanks Dante)
solution

A very neat puzzle! I felt like I needed to deduce and use a range of lemmas and corollaires to solve it.

I’ll try and narrow down the solve path and add it to my solution.

solution

A very neat puzzle! I felt like I needed to deduce and use a range of lemmas and corollaires to solve it.

Before we dive in, a couple of lemmas/corollaries:

Lemma 1: Consider the pattern A-B (- is a grey bar, _ is and number). We must have A > B
Corollaries: 1-
_ and _-6 are impossible configurations
Lemma 2: Consider the pattern --
. The leftmost two numbers must have the same sum as the rightmost 2 numbers

Armed with Lemma 1 we get:

step 1

Applying our corollary to column 3 forces

The 2 in R6C3 with some more cells coming as a result of lemma 1
step 2

Now

To ensure the horizontal bar is in the correct place in column 2, the 3 must be placed in R5C2
step 3

This forces

Row 3 into this unique arrangement with respect to the vertical bar
step 4

This is where we bring in lemma 2

R2C3 must be one more than R5C3. The only consecutive pair of numbers that fit are 4 and 5
step 5

Let’s go back to lemma 1 to get

step 6

Now

The 6 in row 5 can only go in one place to ensure the horizontal bar is in the correct place. This gives a lot more cells via the usual Latin square logic.
step 7

Finally, using lemma 2

In row 4 forces the final unique solution (which I slipped up on in my original submission - thanks Dante)
solution

edited body
Source Link
Toffee
  • 1.2k
  • 5
  • 13
Loading
Source Link
Toffee
  • 1.2k
  • 5
  • 13
Loading