# The man who made it didn't want it [duplicate]

The man who made it didn't want it.

The man who bought it didn't need it.

The man who got it didn't know it.

What is it?

-

## marked as duplicate by Dennis Meng, Will, Mohit Jain, f'', CodeNewbieMar 21 at 7:03

Your attempt? – immibis Mar 20 at 21:46
What are you asking? – Parzival Mar 20 at 22:09
Like people said, it's old and well-known. "Your attempt" makes it sounds like you're saying you invented it. – immibis Mar 20 at 22:15
True, I'll fix it, thank you. – Parzival Mar 20 at 22:15

This is an old one.

Explanation:

The man who makes it, doesn't want to use it, the man who bought it isn't the one who it's for, and the man got it, is dead.

-

Coffin

It's a well known riddle :-)

The one who makes it is still alive(probably).
The one who buys it is also alive.
The one who is dead, and is buried in it doesn't know that he is in the coffin.

-
yeah, i figured it would be, but I didn't see it on the site, so I figured what the heck, maybe it's not. – Parzival Mar 20 at 15:53
Welcome to puzzling.stackexchange :-) The fellow puzzlers have solved many riddles like this, we have innate love for puzzles and encourage any puzzle which provides nutrition to brain. Hope you find your journey enthralling ^_^ – ABcDexter Mar 20 at 15:57
Yeah, I like puzzles, but I think i'm way out of my league. I joined Stack Exchange four days ago, and I'm mostly on Arqade. – Parzival Mar 20 at 16:02
@WalkerNiemeyer I believe it was decided that old puzzles are welcome so we have a set of correct answers to all the classics. Thanks for contributing this one! – Hugh Meyers Mar 20 at 19:26

Is it a

coffin?

That fits and is semi-macabre. The man who made it didn't want it - as in built the coffin and sold it but didn't want it for himself; The man who bought it didn't want it - as in bought it for his deceased loved one but didn't want it for himself, and hopefully not for his dead loved one; The man who got it didn't know it - as in that man is dead and couldn't know it.

Just a stab in the dark. The atom bomb reply earlier made me consider something more, uh, unfortunate an item.

-
Would it be possible for you to edit this answer to explain how you reached this conclusion given the information in the question? – Emrakul Mar 20 at 19:51
2 other people (including the accepted answer) have already given this exact answer before you... – Darrel Hoffman Mar 20 at 19:59

I also think it could be an atom bomb.

The man who made it didn't want it.

They're seen as a necessary evil rather than something wanted

The man who bought it didn't need it.

When sold to warring countries its to those who don't actually need it.

The man who got it didn't know it.

There's no real early warning system that works practically, so they'd have no warning

-
I guess that would work, but not the answer I was looking for, and rather macabre. – Parzival Mar 20 at 18:58
But it does fit though – TheGeorgeL Mar 20 at 18:58
@WalkerNiemeyer - And the intended answer isn't macabre? – Darrel Hoffman Mar 20 at 19:10
Would it be possible for you to edit this answer to explain how you reached this conclusion given the information in the question? – Emrakul Mar 20 at 19:51
@DarrelHoffman not really, much less so than the atom bomb. – Parzival Mar 20 at 19:56